Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Office Depot Loses Summary Judgment in TCPA Text Case
In McGonigle v. Office Depot, 2026 WL 2597936 (S.D. Fla. Aug. 14, 2026), the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida denied Office Depot's motion for summary judgment in a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) class action over text messages. The court rejected each defense argument described below, leaving key questions for trial.
On this page
What the court held
According to an analysis published by TCPAWorld:
- Registration by the plaintiff is not required. The court held a plaintiff can bring a § 227(c) do-not-call claim if the number is on the National Do Not Call Registry, regardless of who registered it.
- No good-faith defense for wrong numbers. Office Depot argued it could rely on consent given by a third party. The Eleventh Circuit rejected that argument in Breslow, and the defense was treated as abandoned.
- Standing. The court applied binding Eleventh Circuit authority holding that unwanted texts cause a concrete injury under Article III.
- Texts are calls, in this court. The court declined to revisit its earlier ruling that texts count as calls, despite more recent decisions elsewhere going the other way.
- Residential use is a jury question. Office Depot argued the plaintiff used the phone only to set up TCPA lawsuits. The court held that how the plaintiff uses the phone is a question of fact.
Why it matters
The text-versus-call question is now split across courts. The Seventh Circuit and several district courts hold texts are not calls under § 227(c)(5). This Florida court, applying its own prior ruling, did not follow them. Where a case is filed can decide it.
The decision also shows the cost of weak arguments. TCPAWorld's view is that arguments foreclosed by binding precedent may have undercut stronger ones.
What this means for you
- Do not assume the text-call split helps you. Check the law in each forum where you text consumers.
- Wrong-number consent is your risk. Consent from a prior subscriber or a third party will not protect you in the Eleventh Circuit.
- A plaintiff's prior lawsuits don't defeat the claim. Challenge residential use with evidence, not assumptions.
- Pick defenses carefully. Lead with your strongest arguments.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
