Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
You Can't Sue Your Way Around Sovereign Immunity: Cunningham v. Lester and the Healthcare.gov Robocalls
What if the robocall came from the government?
On this page
Craig Cunningham got a prerecorded call about Healthcare.gov enrollment. He tried suing the contractor and lost. So he came back and sued three federal employees personally.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit wasn't buying it. In Cunningham v. Lester, No. 20-1086, 990 F.3d 361 (4th Cir. Mar. 4, 2021), Judge Wilkinson, joined by Judges Agee and Diaz, affirmed the dismissal due to sovereign immunity.
So what happened?
The Affordable Care Act requires the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), to set up a system for telling people they may qualify for subsidized health coverage. CMS contracted with a company that later merged into General Dynamics Information Technology, Inc. (GDIT).
CMS employees gave GDIT a script: "Hello, this is an important message from healthcare.gov. The deadline to enroll in a 2016 health insurance plan is coming soon..." Then they told GDIT to prerecord it and send it with an autodialer to about 680,000 people. None had consented.
Cunningham sued GDIT under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The Fourth Circuit tossed that case in 2018, holding GDIT was protected as a government contractor that was just following authorized instructions.
Round two
Here's the thing ... Cunningham refiled with the same basic injuries. But this time he sued three CMS employees in their individual capacities and asked only for money.
Pretty clever. The district court said so too. But it looked past the caption and found the federal government was the real party in interest.
What the Fourth Circuit said
- The TCPA doesn't waive federal immunity. The Supreme Court already said in Campbell-Ewald Co. v. Gomez that the United States and its agencies aren't subject to the TCPA's prohibitions.
- Substance beats form. You don't get around sovereign immunity by putting individual names in the caption. Courts ask who the judgment would really operate against.
- Lewis v. Clarke didn't change that. Cunningham argued that any personal-capacity damages suit is fair game. The court said that case involved a limo driver's own negligence, not officials carrying out a federal mandate.
- The five Martin factors all pointed to the government. The employees were doing their jobs. No one claimed they acted outside their authority or for personal gain.
And the stakes were real. The class action could have hit three employees with a judgment worth hundreds of millions of dollars. The court said letting that happen would make Campbell-Ewald "a practical nullity" and expose every agency contractor partnership to "artful pleading."
Read that again. The court called it what it was.
Why should you care?
Most of you don't work for the federal government. This case doesn't help a private telemarketer.
But it does highlight two important points. First, government calls are mostly off the table under the TCPA. Second, courts look at what a lawsuit really is, not how it's labeled. That cuts both ways for businesses too.
What to do this week
- Don't assume government work protects you. Contractor immunity depends on following valid instructions.
- If you're a contractor, get instructions in writing. That record mattered in round one.
- Everyone else, get consent before prerecorded or autodialed calls.
The court ended by saying robocall grievances like this belong in "the court of public opinion and the legislative branch." Not the federal courts.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
