Regulatory update · Litigation & decisions
The "Anti-Scam" Robocaller Who Got a $116 Million FCC Fine
Here's a story with a twist. A group that said it was fighting scam calls got fined $116,156,250 for making illegal robocalls.
On this page
On September 21, 2023, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) adopted a forfeiture order against Thomas Dorsher, ChariTel Inc, OnTel Inc and ScammerBlaster Inc. The FCC called them the Dorsher Enterprise. All four are jointly and severally liable. The order was released September 22.
So what happened?
According to the FCC, between January 1 and March 2, 2021, ChariTel made 9,763,599 prerecorded voice message calls to toll free numbers.
The messages described themselves as a "public service announcement." The FCC's press release says that they "ranted about the harms associated with scam calls" and urged recipients to report scam calls to regulators, phone carriers and ScammerBlaster.
Sounds noble, right? Here's the catch.
Here's the thing ...
When you call a toll free number, the business that owns that number pays for the call. Not you. The FCC says that is exactly why the Dorsher Enterprise chose toll free numbers.
According to the FCC, the local carrier that got fees from these calls shared them as credits with the Dorsher Enterprise. The forfeiture order states that the carrier paid ChariTel $0.0001 for each minute of outbound calls to toll free numbers. And the FCC says that money was used to fund OnTel's telephone denial of service (TDoS) attacks on other companies. A TDoS attack is a flood of calls meant to tie up a phone line.
The law is simple on this one. You can't send prerecorded calls to numbers where the person called gets charged, unless you have prior express consent or an emergency. That's in the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).
How did they get to $116 million?
The FCC verified 20,650 unlawful prerecorded calls. It started with a base fine of $4,500 per call. Then it bumped that up to $5,625 per call because the conduct was egregious, citing the use of toll free robocalls to fund TDoS attacks.
20,650 calls times $5,625 equals $116,156,250.
The FCC first proposed the fine in a Notice of Apparent Liability on July 14, 2022. Dorsher pushed back with several arguments, including mistaken identity, a claim that toll free customers aren't charged for calls, and a good faith or public safety defense. The FCC rejected them all and didn't reduce the fine by a penny. It also said the Dorsher Enterprise wasn't entitled to a warning first.
Separately, a federal grand jury indicted Dorsher and others on November 22, 2022, for criminal charges relating to the TDoS attacks. This case is separate from the FCC action. An indictment is only an allegation, and the defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty.
Why should you care?
Two big lessons. First, your motive doesn't matter if your calls break the rules. "I was fighting scammers" didn't save anybody here.
Second, toll free numbers are covered. If you're blasting prerecorded messages at 800 numbers to rack up traffic, you're asking for this.
What to do this week
- Check your call lists for toll free numbers. Prerecorded calls to them need consent.
- Watch for traffic pumping. If a carrier deal pays you for outbound minutes to toll free numbers, run.
- Know that intent counts. The FCC found these violations intentional, and intentional TCPA violations have a four year statute of limitations.
That's it. Good intentions don't make illegal robocalls legal.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
