Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Smith v. ExamWorks: Appointment Reminder Class Denied
In Smith v. ExamWorks, LLC, No. 8:21-cv-02746-PX (D. Md. Sept. 21, 2026), Judge Xinis refused to certify a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) class over prerecorded medical appointment reminders, and along the way explained what "prior express consent" actually covers.
On this page
The setup
ExamWorks schedules independent medical exams for insurance claimants, including claimants of Government Employees Insurance Company (GEICO). The insurer passes along the claimant's "best contact" number, and ExamWorks schedulers often talk to claimants directly. Then an automated system may place a reminder: "This is an important message for [claimant's name] regarding an upcoming medical examination..."
Michael Smith was a passenger in a car driven by a GEICO insured. He said the reminders went to one of his two cell numbers that he never gave out, and that they kept coming after his lawyer revoked consent. He sought to represent everyone who got prerecorded reminders on a cell number they didn't give to ExamWorks. His expert identified 5,552 numbers.
Why the class failed
Ascertainability. ExamWorks schedulers routinely got or confirmed numbers directly from claimants, but didn't consistently log it. Sorting class members from non-members would mean digging through individual case notes.
Typicality. Smith's claim really turned on the insurer using the wrong number and his lawyer's revocation, not on whether he gave ExamWorks a number. He also testified that he no longer had the phone that received the reminders, which created evidence problems unique to him.
Adequacy. The court found Smith knew almost nothing about the case, including what state it was filed in, and noted his testimony that he never knew about a $20,000 individual settlement offer. The court also voiced concern about a fee provision that could swallow an individual settlement, though it declined to find counsel inadequate and said ethics issues belong with disciplinary bodies.
Predominance. Smith argued the big common question was legal: after Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024), does consent mean consent to robocalls specifically, not just handing over a number? The court said no. "Prior express consent" modifies "any call," so you consent to the call, not the prerecorded voice. Giving your number for a particular purpose is consent to calls about that purpose, consistent with Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulings and the Fifth Circuit's decision in Bradford v. Sovereign Pest Control of TX, Inc., No. 24-20379 (5th Cir. Feb. 25, 2026). And even under Smith's theory, whether each claimant agreed to robocalls would need individual inquiry.
Class certification denied.
Why it matters
Informational calls tied to the reason someone gave their number are on solid footing in this court. And classes built on consent questions that depend on one-on-one conversations are tough to certify.
Takeaways
- Log how and when you got each number, including verbal confirmations.
- Keep reminder calls tied to the purpose the person gave the number for.
- Honor revocations, including ones that come through a lawyer.
- Plaintiffs: preserve the phone and records tied to the calls.
General information only, not legal advice.
Read the District of Maryland's opinion in Smith v. ExamWorks.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
