Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Latner v. Mount Sinai: One Flu Shot Reminder Text Was Covered by Consent
Can a doctor's office text you a flu shot reminder without violating the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA)? In Latner v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., No. 17-99-cv, 879 F.3d 52 (2d Cir. Jan. 3, 2018), amended Jan. 9, 2018, the Second Circuit said yes, at least on these facts, because the patient had consented.
On this page
What happened
Back in 2003, Daniel Latner went to West Park Medical Group, a Mount Sinai facility, for a checkup. He filled out new patient forms with his contact information and signed a form consenting to the use of his health information "for payment, treatment and hospital operations purposes." The privacy notices said the practice could use his information "to recommend possible treatment alternatives or health-related benefits and services."
In 2011, Mount Sinai hired a vendor, PromptALERT, to send mass messages, including flu shot reminders. Latner visited the practice again that November and declined immunizations. In September 2014, he received one text message:
"Its flu season again. Your PCP at WPMG is thinking of you! Please call us at 212-247-8100 to schedule an appointment for a flu shot."
That was the only one. Mount Sinai said it sent the reminder to every active patient seen in the prior three years. Latner sued under the autodialer provision, and the Southern District of New York granted judgment on the pleadings.
What the court held
Judge Cabranes wrote for the panel. The court affirmed, but for a different reason than the district court.
The healthcare exception isn't the whole story. The district court relied on a Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rule that exempts certain HIPAA-covered "health care" messages from the prior written consent requirement for telemarketing. The Second Circuit agreed the text was a health care message. But that exception only removes the written consent requirement. The call still needed ordinary prior express consent, and the district court never decided that.
Van Patten on the scope of consent
Latner consented. Under the FCC's guidance, the scope of consent depends on "the facts of each situation." Latner gave his number, agreed his information could be used for treatment, and received notices saying it could be used to recommend health-related services. So he consented to "a single text message about a 'health-related benefit[]' that might have been of interest to him."
The 2015 exemption didn't apply. The court also noted that if the district court meant to rely on the FCC's 2015 healthcare treatment exemption, that wouldn't work. The exemption came after the 2014 text, and nothing in the FCC's order suggested it was retroactive.
Why this matters
Latner is a narrow but useful ruling for healthcare providers. A patient's intake paperwork and privacy notices can provide consent for treatment-related reminders. The court took note of the fact that this was one text sent to an active patient about care he might want.
Practical points:
- Make intake forms and privacy notices clear about health-related outreach by text or call.
- Remember that health care messages still need prior express consent, even when written consent isn't required.
- Keep reminders tied to treatment, not general promotion.
- Limit frequency and honor opt-outs.
Read the Second Circuit's amended opinion in Latner v. Mount Sinai.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Amended opinion, Latner v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., No. 17-99-cv (2d Cir. Jan. 9, 2018)
- Amended opinion, Latner v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., No. 17-99-cv (2d Cir. Jan. 9, 2018) (2)
- Original opinion (Jan. 3, 2018)
- Amended opinion, Latner v. Mount Sinai Health System, Inc., No. 17-99-cv (2d Cir. Jan. 9, 2018).
