Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Baisden v. Credit Adjustments: Hospital Admission Forms Can Supply Prior Express Consent
In Baisden v. Credit Adjustments, Inc., No. 15-3411, 813 F.3d 338 (6th Cir. Feb. 12, 2016), the Sixth Circuit held that patients who give a cell phone number to a hospital, and authorize the hospital to release their information for billing, can give prior express consent under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) to collection calls from an affiliated physicians' group and its debt collector.
On this page
Background
Zachary Baisden and Brenda Sissoko received anesthesiology services at Mount Carmel Hospital in Columbus, Ohio, from Consultant Anesthesiologists. Their unpaid bills, totaling a little over one thousand dollars, were referred to Credit Adjustments, which called their cell phones using an automatic telephone dialing system and prerecorded voice. Credit Adjustments got the numbers from the physicians' group, which had received them from the hospital.
At admission, the plaintiffs signed consent forms. The 2011 form allowed Mount Carmel to use health information "for many reasons as needed," including "billing and payment," and to "receive or release" that information. Sissoko's 2009 form authorized release to "companies who provide billing services for physicians or other providers involved in my medical care." The Southern District of Ohio granted summary judgment to Credit Adjustments.
The Court's Analysis
Judge Griffin wrote for a panel that included Judge Batchelder and District Judge Carr, sitting by designation.
Hobbs Act limits. Because this was not a direct appeal from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), the court lacked jurisdiction to question the validity of the FCC's interpretations of "prior express consent." The case turned on applying them.
Consent through an intermediary. The plaintiffs relied on the FCC's 2008 statement that consent is deemed granted only if the number "was provided by the consumer to the creditor." The court rejected that narrow reading. Drawing on the FCC's 1992 Order, 2008 Ruling, 2014 GroupMe ruling and 2015 Order, and adopting the Eleventh Circuit's reasoning in Mais v. Gulf Coast Collection Bureau, the court held that consent may be obtained and conveyed through an intermediary. The FCC's rulings make "no distinction between directly providing one's cell phone number to a creditor and taking steps to make that number available through other methods."
Van Patten on the scope of consent
The authorizations. The court examined each form separately. The 2009 form was virtually indistinguishable from the one in Mais. Reading "health information" in light of the federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) definition, the court held it includes contact information related to payment; otherwise, the billing authorization would be meaningless. The form's one-year limit applied only to the separate authorization covering drug, alcohol and HIV information. The broader 2011 form likewise supplied consent.
Transaction requirement. Following its decision in Hill v. Homeward Residential, the court rejected the argument that the number must be given during the "initial" transaction creating the debt. The number must be given in connection with the debt, which it was.
The court affirmed.
Practical Takeaways
- Healthcare creditors and collectors should obtain the actual admission forms and confirm they authorize release of information for billing and collection.
- Consent through an intermediary depends on the specific language and context; generic forms may not be enough.
- Consumers can still revoke consent through reasonable means.
The Third Circuit later distinguished this line of cases in Daubert v. NRA Group, where no such form appeared in the record.
Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Baisden v. Credit Adjustments.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
