Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Sage Telecom v. Mercantile Adjustment Bureau: A Phone Carrier Is Not a "Purchaser" Under Texas's Telemarketer Registration Law
Texas requires sellers who make telephone solicitations into or from the state to register with the Secretary of State. In Sage Telecom, Inc. v. Mercantile Adjustment Bureau, LLC, No. 3:22-CV-2737-D (N.D. Tex. Apr. 4, 2023), Senior Judge Sidney A. Fitzwater held that a telecommunications carrier could not state a claim under that law based on calls to its subscribers, because the carrier itself was not alleged to be a "purchaser."
On this page
Background
The plaintiff operates a free wireless telephone program through the federal Lifeline Program, which provides discounted phone and internet service to qualifying households. As a Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulated carrier, it must report the number and length of calls made to Lifeline members.
The plaintiff alleged that the defendant, a debt collector, made indiscriminate telephone solicitations to Lifeline members to negotiate and sell off debt, without obtaining the registration, paying the filing fee, or posting the $10,000 security required by § 302.101 of the Texas Telephone Solicitation Act. It claimed the calls put the accuracy of its government reporting at risk and exposed it to enhanced FCC scrutiny. It sued in state court to protect its members and itself, and the defendant removed.
Hyde v. Kirkendall Dwyer on Texas registration claims
The Statutory Elements
Section 302.101(a) provides that "[a] seller may not make a telephone solicitation from a location in this state or to a purchaser located in this state unless the seller holds a registration certificate." The defendant argued that the plaintiff failed to plead that the defendant was a seller, that it made telephone solicitations, and that the plaintiff was a purchaser. The plaintiff responded that these definitional questions turned on competing views of the defendant's business and could not be resolved on the pleadings.
The Carrier Never Received a Call
The court did not decide whether the defendant was a seller or whether the calls were solicitations. It found a more basic defect. The plaintiff did not allege that the calls were made "from a location in this state," so it needed to allege calls "to a purchaser located in this state."
The statute defines a "purchaser" as a person who "is solicited to become or becomes obligated for the purchase or rental of an item" or "is offered an opportunity to claim or receive an item." The amended complaint alleged that at least 187 Lifeline subscribers received solicitations. It did not allege that the plaintiff itself received a single call. Without that, the plaintiff could not plausibly claim it was "solicited" or "offered" anything. The only reasonable inference was that the subscribers, not the carrier, were the purchasers.
Allegations about the purpose of the calls might satisfy other elements, but they did not make the plaintiff a purchaser.
Leave to Replead
Because there was no indication the plaintiff could not or would not cure the defects, the court dismissed the claim and granted 28 days to file a second amended complaint.
Takeaways
- The purchaser element matters. A § 302.101 claim requires a solicitation from Texas or to a purchaser in Texas, and the plaintiff must fit the statutory definition.
- Indirect harm is not enough. A business affected by calls to its customers is not a purchaser unless it was itself solicited.
- Plead both location prongs carefully. Failing to allege a Texas origin puts the full weight on the purchaser element.
Read the full Northern District of Texas opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
