Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Ohio Sued 12 Defendants Over "Car Warranty" Robocalls. Here's How It Ended.
Here's the thing about "your car's extended warranty" calls. Everyone hates them. And Ohio decided to go after the people selling the contracts, not just the people dialing.
On this page
On January 5, 2023, Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost announced a lawsuit against six individuals and six companies. The lawsuit was filed in the Franklin County Common Pleas Court, Case No. 23CV000047.
So what happened?
According to Yost, Delaware-based Pelican Investment Holdings paid for leads. Those leads came from outbound prerecorded calls pitching "vehicle service contracts." These contracts were administered by Dimension Service, Autoguard Advantage and National Administrative Service, all based in Dublin, Ohio.
Seven Follow-Up Calls and a 30-Page Contract: CarShield Pays $10 Million to the FTC
The state claims the prerecorded calls:
- Didn't properly identify the caller.
- Claimed to be about extending the consumer's auto warranty.
- Claimed to be affiliated with the auto manufacturer.
Ohio claims none of that was true. The calls were really about selling service contracts.
The state also says that when calls led to a sale, the defendants didn't get a signed written confirmation of the verbal agreement. And they acted as telephone solicitors without registering with the Attorney General's office or filing the required surety bond. Those are violations of Ohio's Telephone Solicitation Sales Act. The misleading calls also allegedly broke the Consumer Sales Practices Act.
Who got sued?
The companies: Pelican Investment Holdings, Dimension Service Corp., Autoguard Advantage Corp, National Administrative Service Co., Falcon Endeavors Inc. and MB Holdings Group.
The individuals: Gustave C. Renny, Vajira Samararatne, Stacey E. Yim, Ronald D. Eddington Jr., Joseph E. Hill Jr. and Haytham H. Elzayn.
Here's the thing ...
Yost said something telling: "Interestingly, after our initial subpoena, they stopped calling people who have Ohio area codes but continued to call Ohioans with area codes from other states."
Ha. Nice try. Ohio residents with out-of-state numbers are still Ohio residents.
How it ended
According to the Ohio Attorney General's 2024 Consumer Protection Annual Report:
- October 9, 2023: Four consent judgments resolved the case against Pelican, Renny, Samararatne, Eddington, Hill, Falcon Endeavors and MB Holdings. Together they included a declaratory judgment, a permanent injunction and a $200,000 civil penalty, with $100,000 suspended if they fully comply.
- February 28, 2024: Four consent judgments resolved the case against Elzayn, Dimension Service, Autoguard Advantage and National Administrative Service. Terms included a declaratory judgment, a permanent injunction and a $50,000 civil penalty, with $30,000 suspended if they fully comply.
- July 10, 2024: After a default judgment on May 22, 2024, the court entered a final judgment ordering Stacey Yim to pay a $50,000 civil penalty.
Why should you care?
Look at who got hit. Not just the lead buyer. The administrators who backed the contracts got pulled in too. If your company's product is being sold through robocalls, you can end up as a defendant.
What to do this week
- Know how your leads are generated. Prerecorded "warranty" calls are a giant red flag.
- Register where you have to. Ohio requires telephone solicitors to register and post a bond.
- Get written confirmations. Ohio requires them for phone sales.
That's it. If the pitch starts with a lie, the whole chain is exposed.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
