Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Newell v. Children's Dental Health Associates: A Checkup Reminder to a Stranger Can Be a Solicitation
Two friendly texts from a dental office, one offering to "book an appt" and one urging a checkup for a named child the complaint does not connect to the recipient. Harmless reminders, or telemarketing to a number on the National Do Not Call Registry? In Newell v. Children's Dental Health Associates, LLC, No. 25-5238 (E.D. Pa. Apr. 6, 2026), Judge Murphy let the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) claim proceed, while tossing the request for an injunction.
On this page
The Texts
The plaintiff registered his residential number in March 2025. In May and June 2025, he got two texts from the same dental office number, each with a booking link and "reply STOP" language. The second named a child and suggested a summer check-up. He says he was never a patient and never inquired. He replied to the second text asking the office to cease and desist, and no more texts are alleged.
No Injunction Without a Threat
Standing for an injunction requires a real and immediate threat of future harm. Two texts, no alleged texts after the stop request, and nothing else meant no standing for injunctive relief. The plaintiff tried to add in his brief that texts continued after he said stop, but a complaint cannot be amended through an opposition brief. That part was dismissed without prejudice.
Texts Are Calls (Again, in This District)
The office argued texts are not "telephone calls" under the Do Not Call private right of action. Applying McLaughlin Chiropractic v. McKesson, which lets courts read the statute independently while giving the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) appropriate respect, the court sided with the broader view. In 1991, to call meant to communicate by telephone, not necessarily by voice. The court also pointed to the Supreme Court's statement in Campbell-Ewald that a text is a call under ยง 227(b), and to Congress's 2018 caller ID amendment covering text services. It rejected rulings from other districts that reached the opposite conclusion, including the Northern District of Georgia and the Southern District of Indiana. Reading "call" differently across subsections would create, in the court's words, potentially "absurd inconsistencies."
"Use" Versus "Pay"
The most interesting argument: the texts encouraged the recipient to use dental services, not pay for them, so they were not "telephone solicitations." The office leaned on Hulce v. Zipongo, where the Seventh Circuit found no solicitation in messages about free services under a state Medicaid plan. But nothing suggested these dental services were free, so it was plausible the texts aimed to get the recipient to pay.
A Name Does Not Prove a Relationship
The office also argued that naming a patient showed a prior relationship and an appointment reminder. Not so fast. The court followed Wilson v. Skopos Financial, which inferred that texts to the "wrong name" could be a pretext to start a commercial relationship. Taking the plaintiff's allegations as true, whether an exception applies needs discovery into the texts' "true purpose and intended recipient."
Takeaways
- Healthcare marketers: Recall texts to numbers you cannot tie to a patient carry risk on registered lines.
- Defendants: The free-services argument works only when the services really are free.
- Plaintiffs: Plead post-stop contacts in the complaint if you want an injunction.
- Everyone: Courts remain divided on whether texts are calls under the Do Not Call private right of action, so the forum matters.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
