Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
McMorrow v. Core Properties: Summary Judgment for the Plaintiff Over Home Purchase Offer Texts
In McMorrow v. Core Properties, LLC, No. 4:23-cv-00126-JAR (E.D. Mo. Dec. 15, 2023), Judge John A. Ross granted the plaintiff partial summary judgment on liability under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The court held that unsolicited texts offering to buy a home were "telephone solicitations" and "telemarketing" because the offer came bundled with home-selling services paid for through an "effective fee." It also held a brand licensor vicariously liable under apparent authority.
On this page
Undisputed Facts
Growth Development, LLC acquires and resells real estate. It licensed the name, branding, and website of Core Properties, LLC, which had become an intellectual property holding company. Growth Development used analytics data to identify likely sellers and sent their numbers to a texting vendor, 1000 Calls a Day, without scrubbing them against the National Do Not Call Registry or obtaining consent. It also signed a "Do Not Call Waiver" releasing the vendor from liability for contacting registered numbers.
Shafer v. Toyota of Boardman: "Want to Sell Your Camry?" Can Still Be a Sales Text
The plaintiff, who had registered his cell number in 2008 and used it as his residential line, received four texts between July 2022 and January 2023 about buying his home. When he asked for a website, the vendor sent a link to corepropertiesstl.com. The texts did not identify the sender or provide contact information. Between 2022 and mid-2023, the campaign generated 47 transactions. In 24, Growth Development bought and resold the property the same day at a higher price without disclosing the resale price to the seller. In 14, it assigned its purchase right for a fee.
The Effective Fee
The only liability dispute was purpose. The defendants said the texts were offers to purchase, not solicitations to buy anything. The court disagreed, relying on Eagle v. GVG Capital (W.D. Mo. 2023), Pepper v. GVG Capital (S.D. Tex. 2023), and the reasoning in Anderson v. Catalina Structured Funding. It also relied on Federal Communications Commission (FCC) guidance from 2005 that calls by real estate agents offering services to owners are solicitations, while calls by buyer's agents to owners who advertised their property are not. The plaintiff had not advertised his home.
Growth Development chose the title company and paid closing costs. That, the court said, "is a service." Its profit from same-day resales and assignment fees was an effective fee paid by sellers, who gave up the higher price. Whether the business exactly matched a real estate agent's was not controlling. It distinguished it from Jance v. Homerun Offer, in which the plaintiff alleged only an offer to purchase.
With purpose resolved, Growth Development was liable on both counts: the registry claim under 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(c)(2) and the sender identification claim under § 64.1200(d)(4).
Apparent Authority Through a Brand License
Core Properties did not control the texting campaign, so there was no formal agency. But the FCC's 2013 Dish Network ruling lists authority to use a principal's trade name as evidence of apparent authority. Core Properties licensed its name and website, and the vendor sent the plaintiff to that website, giving him a reasonable belief that Core Properties was the sender. The manner-and-means control test applies to formal agency, not apparent authority.
Practical Points
- Purchase offers can be solicitations. Where profit depends on resale or assignment, courts may find an implicit service and fee.
- Brand licensing carries exposure. A licensor whose name and website appear in a campaign can face apparent authority liability.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
