Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Margulis v. Resort Cancellation Services: Missouri's Two-Year Clock, a Thin Conspiracy Claim, and an Owner Who Stays In
Some telemarketing cases are decided by one big question. Margulis v. Resort Cancellation Services, LLC, No. 4:25 CV 945 CDP (E.D. Mo. Oct. 2, 2025), came down to four smaller ones. Judge Catherine D. Perry's short order shows how timing, pleading detail and service deadlines can trim a case even when the core claim survives.
On this page
The Setup
The plaintiff said the company, its owner and ten unidentified "John Doe" callers placed unsolicited calls to her residential number, even though it was on both the national and Missouri Do Not Call lists. She alleged more than fifteen calls starting in August 2022 and continuing, but her exhibit identified five: three in August 2022, one in September 2024 and one in February 2025.
She sued in Missouri state court in April 2025 under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), Missouri's no-call law and Missouri's telemarketing laws, and added a civil conspiracy claim. The defendants removed the case to federal court and moved to dismiss part of it.
Round One: Missouri's Two-Year Limit
The Missouri claims sit within the Missouri Merchandising Practices Act. Its no-call and telemarketing provisions bar suits filed more than two years after the plaintiff knew or should have known of the violation. With the complaint filed on April 8, 2025, any call before April 8, 2023 was out, including the three August 2022 calls. Those Missouri claims were dismissed with prejudice, but claims based on later calls continue.
The defendants didn't seek to dismiss the federal claim on timing grounds, so this ruling affected only the state law claims.
Round Two: "Meeting of the Minds" Isn't Enough
The conspiracy claim alleges that the company and its owner aided or ratified the Doe callers' illegal calls. Beyond a bare statement that "there was a meeting of the minds," the complaint gave no facts showing an agreement to break the TCPA or Missouri law. The claim was dismissed without prejudice.
Round Three: The Owner Stays In
The owner argued he couldn't be personally liable under the TCPA. In the Eighth Circuit, direct liability requires that the defendant actually initiated the call by taking the steps needed to physically place it. The complaint alleged that the owner "participated in the solicitation calls" and personally took part in making the calls to the plaintiff. At the pleading stage, that was enough. Whether it can be proven is a question for later.
Round Four: Serve the Does or Lose Them
After removal, the plaintiff had 90 days to serve any unserved defendant. That deadline passed with the John Does still unidentified and unserved, so the court ordered her to show cause why they shouldn't be dismissed without prejudice.
Takeaways
- Check state law clocks separately. A state telemarketing claim can have a much shorter limitations period than the federal claim that you file alongside it.
- Conspiracy needs facts. Words like "meeting of the minds" don't plead an agreement.
- Owners can be named directly. Allegations that an owner personally took part in the calls survive a motion to dismiss.
- Doe defendants have a deadline. Unknown callers must be identified and served on time, or they drop out of the case.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
