Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Hubble v. loanDepot: A Mortgage Lender Swings for a First-Round Knockout on Class Claims and Misses
Judge Thomas L. Ludington opened his opinion in Hubble v. loanDepot.com, LLC, No. 1:24-cv-11173 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 23, 2025) with a boxing metaphor. Beating class certification, he wrote, is like winning a split decision after twelve rounds of discovery and briefing. So some defendants swing for a first-round knockout by moving to strike class allegations before discovery. The mortgage lender here tried it. It missed.
On this page
The Calls
According to the complaint, the lender started placing live and prerecorded sales calls to the plaintiff in January 2024, pitching mortgage and loan products. He told live representatives that he was not interested and asked them to stop. He called the company himself and heard "To opt-out of further calls, press one," and pressed one. He later spoke to a live person and asked them again. The calls continued about 48 in less than a month after asking them to stop, he alleges, including some prerecorded voicemails.
He sued the company under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) on behalf of a "Prerecorded Class" of people the company called with an artificial or prerecorded voice for the same purpose, and a "Pre-recorded Stop Class" of people called with a prerecorded voice after asking not to be contacted.
Round One: "Who Got Called?"
The lender argued "called" was too vague. Did it mean the person the lender was trying to reach, the person who answered, or the subscriber? The judge agreed the lender "has a point." TCPA classes are usually defined by who owns the number. But courts have certified classes defined just as loosely, including the Sixth Circuit's approval of a class of "all persons who were successfully sent a facsimile." Any fine-tuning can wait for class certification and judges have broad discretion to modify definitions.
Round Two: "What About People Who Consented?"
The company also argued the classes were overbroad because they could include people who agreed to the calls, who would lack standing. The court pointed to Bridging Communities Inc. v. Top Flite Financial Inc., 843 F.3d 1119 (6th Cir. 2016). There, the Sixth Circuit held that a TCPA class need not expressly exclude people who consented, since discovery may show a class-wide absence of consent.
Then came the knockout line. Lack of consent is a part of TCPA liability, so a class defined as people who did not consent is a "failsafe" class, which courts prohibit. This would put plaintiffs in a catch-22: define your TCPA class in terms of consent and have it struck as failsafe, or leave consent out and have it struck as overbroad. The court would not set that trap. The motion was denied.
Corner Advice
- For defendants: Pre-discovery motions to strike are disfavored. They work in the Sixth Circuit only when certification is impossible no matter what discovery shows. A vagueness or consent argument usually belongs at class certification.
- For plaintiffs: Defining classes by call type and conduct, such as prerecorded calls after a stop request, can survive early attack even without excluding consenting members.
- For everyone: Opt-out menus are only as good as the systems behind them. Allegations that pressing one did nothing set up a class theory.
Compare a California court's ruling in Barnes v. Coca-Cola, which struck a class defined as everyone who ever got a call. Definitions that track the alleged violation fare far better.
Read the Eastern District of Michigan opinion denying the motion to strike.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion and Order Denying Defendant's Pre-Discovery Motion to Strike Class Allegations, Hubble v. loanDepot.com, LLC, No. 1:24-cv-11173 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 23, 2025)
- Bridging Communities Inc. v. Top Flite Financial Inc., 843 F.3d 1119 (6th Cir. 2016)
- Opinion and Order Denying Defendant's Pre-Discovery Motion to Strike Class Allegations, Hubble v. loanDepot.com, LLC, No. 1:24-cv-11173 (E.D. Mich. Sept. 23, 2025).
