Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Barnes v. Coca-Cola: Delivery Reminder Calls, an "Every Caller" Class, and the Limits of Comity
In a recent decision a federal court in California dismissed a consumer's request for treble damages and struck his nationwide class allegations against a beverage company, with leave to amend. Barnes v. The Coca-Cola Company, No. 1:22-cv-01511 (E.D. Cal. order dated Apr. 4, 2025, filed Apr. 7, 2025), offers three useful points on pleading prerecorded call claims under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).
On this page
Background
The plaintiff alleged that the company placed a series of prerecorded calls and voicemails to his phone reminding him about an "upcoming delivery," and that he never consented. He asserted knowing or willful violations of the TCPA and sought to represent a class of everyone in the United States who received a call on a landline or cell phone "made by or on behalf of" the defendant.
A Reminder Is Not Telemarketing
The court explained that the type of consent required depends on the nature of the call. Under Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rules, a prerecorded call that includes an advertisement or constitutes telemarketing requires prior express written consent; other calls require only prior express consent.
As described in the complaint, the calls only reminded the plaintiff about a delivery. They did not encourage a purchase or promote a product. In his opposition, the plaintiff supplied a fuller transcript that included an invitation to "press 1 to be connected to a beverage expert" to place an order. The court considered only the complaint, which did not allege facts permitting an inference that the calls were advertisements or telemarketing. It dismissed the willful violation claim with leave to amend.
An Overbroad Class Can Be Struck Early
Motions to strike class allegations at the pleading stage are disfavored in the Ninth Circuit but are not improper per se. The proposed class covered every person who had ever received a call from the company. It had no time limit and was not limited to prerecorded calls or calls made without consent. Relying on Olean Wholesale Grocery Cooperative, Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods LLC, 31 F.4th 651 (9th Cir. 2022), the court found the class very likely included uninjured persons and was fatally overbroad. The plaintiff's promise to refine the definition later was not enough, because a defendant is entitled to know the class being alleged against it.
Comity Did Not Justify Striking
The defendant also argued that a Florida federal court's rejection of a similar class should bar any class here. The court disagreed. It noted that the Eleventh Circuit requires a call to be unwanted to cause a concrete injury, while in the Ninth Circuit receipt of an unsolicited call in violation of the TCPA is itself enough, citing Hall v. Smosh Dot Com, Inc., 72 F.4th 983 (9th Cir. 2023). Those differences were enough at the pleading stage to preclude striking the class on comity grounds.
Takeaways
- Plead the content. If a prerecorded call contains a sales pitch, the complaint should say so. Facts first raised in a brief will not save a deficient pleading.
- Define the class around the violation. Classes limited by time period, call type and lack of consent are far harder to strike.
- Comity is persuasive, not binding. Differences in circuit law on standing can blunt a defendant's reliance on an out-of-circuit class ruling.
- Sealing has limits. The court ordered the defendant to show cause why its sealed briefing should not be unsealed.
Read the Eastern District of California order in Barnes v. Coca-Cola.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Order, Barnes v. The Coca-Cola Company, No. 1:22-cv-01511 (E.D. Cal. filed Apr. 7, 2025)
- Olean Wholesale Grocery Cooperative, Inc. v. Bumble Bee Foods LLC, 31 F.4th 651 (9th Cir. 2022)
- Hall v. Smosh Dot Com, Inc., 72 F.4th 983 (9th Cir. 2023)
- Order, Barnes v. The Coca-Cola Company, No. 1:22-cv-01511 (E.D. Cal. filed Apr. 7, 2025).
