Analysis · Do Not Call
Grand Bahama Cruise Line Defendants Banned From Robocalling After FTC "Free Cruise" Case
In September 2021, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) announced a settlement with the last seven defendants in its case against Florida-based Grand Bahama Cruise Line LLC (GBCL). The settlement permanently bans them from making robocalls to consumers. It followed January 2020 settlements with four other defendants including a call center.
On this page
The bottom line: the FTC held liable not only the company that was selling the cruises, but also the people and the call centers who helped to place the calls.
Here is what happened
According to the FTC's complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida (case no. 6:20-cv-00052-RBD-GJK), the GBCL operation made or facilitated millions of illegal calls nationwide offering free cruise vacations between Florida and the Bahamas.
The FTC alleged that the operation:
- Ran its own in-house call center and, through 2017, hired outside call centers to market the cruise packages.
- Bought call lists from lead generators that ran illegal survey robocalls to identify potential customers.
- Delivered millions of illegal robocalls through 2018.
- Called numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry without scrubbing its lists.
- Called consumers who had asked not to be called.
- Failed to transmit accurate caller ID information.
Each of these, the FTC said, violated the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR). Read the FTC's complaint against Grand Bahama Cruise Line.
The settlements
January 2020. Christopher A. Cotroneo, call center Cabb Group, LLC and Christina and Robert J. Peterson II agreed to orders banning them from robocalling including assisting others who robocall. The judgments totaled more than $7.8 million, suspended because of inability to pay except for $2,500 from Cotroneo. Andrew Smith, then Director of the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection, said the case illustrated that "anyone who provides substantial assistance to illegal robocall operations may be liable for substantial civil penalties."
September 2021. The remaining defendants were Johnathan Blake Curtis, Anthony DiGiacomo, Grand Bahama Cruise Line, LLC, Ultimate Vacation Group (doing business as Royal Bahamas Cruise Line, LLC), Tropical Accommodations, LLC (doing business as Grand Celebration Cruise Line), VSC, LLC and Florida V.S.C. Inc. The order:
- Permanently bans them from making robocalls or assisting others in doing so.
- Bars calls to numbers on the Do Not Call Registry unless they have prior express written consent or meet other specific conditions.
- Bars blocking or misrepresenting caller ID information.
- Imposes a $6.4 million civil penalty, partially suspended once Curtis and DiGiacomo each pay $50,000 to the U.S. Treasury.
Why it matters
Two lessons stand out. First, a "survey" robocall that is actually a lead generation tool is still a robocall under the TSR. Second, the companies that buy those leads and the call centers that work them are within reach of the same rule.
What this means for you
- Ask how every purchased lead list was generated. If the answer involves prerecorded survey calls, do not use it.
- Scrub every list against the Do Not Call Registry and your internal do-not-call list.
- Transmit accurate caller ID on every call.
- If you run a call center for a client, check the client's lead sources before you dial.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- FTC case page, Grand Bahama Cruise Line, LLC
- FTC, "Defendants Who Helped Blast Consumers With Millions of Cruise Line Robocalls Settle FTC Complaint" (Jan. 2020)
- FTC, "Seven Remaining Defendants in Massive Grand Bahama Cruise Line Operation Banned From Making Telemarketing Robocalls" (Sept. 2021)
- FTC complaint, FTC v. Grand Bahama Cruise Line, LLC, et al., No. 6:20-cv-00052-RBD-GJK (M.D. Fla.).
