Analysis · Do Not Call
Caribbean Cruise Line: The "Political Survey" That Was Really a Cruise Pitch
Do you want to know how to change a legal robocall into an illegal one? Simply add a sales pitch to it! That's basically the story of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and ten state attorneys general versus Caribbean Cruise Line.
On this page
Who Sued Whom
On March 3, 2015, the FTC and the States of Colorado, Florida, Indiana, Kansas, Mississippi, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio, Tennessee, and Washington filed a joint complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida (Case No. 0:15-cv-60423). Defendants included Caribbean Cruise Line, Inc. (CCL), Linked Service Solutions, LLC and its owners Scott Broomfield and Jason Birkett, Economic Strategy LLC and its owner Jacob deJongh, Steve Hamilton, and Fred Accuardi with five telecom companies including Pacific Telecom Communications Group and T M Caller ID, LLC.
The Clever (Illegal) Plan
According to the complaint, the lead generation plan needed two things: political action committees that wanted free survey robocalls, and a lead buyer that would pay for transfers. deJongh offered PACs millions of free survey calls if he could add a pitch at the beginning and end. Most agreed.
Foodsmart on calls offering a free dietitian
The message went something like: "Hello, this is John from Political Opinions of America. You've been carefully selected to participate in a short 30 second research survey and for participating you'll receive a free two day cruise for two people to the Bahamas."
Press 1 after the survey, and you were transferred to a CCL telemarketer, who mentioned $59 per person in port taxes and pitched hotels, excursions, and upgrades. CCL agreed to pay between $2 and $3 per lead. The FTC said the campaign ran from October 2011 through July 2012 and was averaging about 12 to 15 million illegal sales calls a day.
The Phone Number Plumbing
The Accuardi companies were charged with assisting and facilitating. According to the FTC, they provided the robocallers with hundreds of phone numbers and allowed the robocallers to choose and change the names on the caller ID and to hide themselves from the authorities and shared the caller ID name lookup fees with them.
The Charges
The Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) counts against the cruise call defendants were:
- Calling numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry
- Ignoring entity-specific do not call requests
- Failing to transmit caller ID
- Making unlawful prerecorded sales calls
Plus a TSR assisting and facilitating count against the Pacific Telecom group and state law claims under Florida, Missouri, North Carolina, and Ohio law.
The FTC's point was that its rules don't prohibit political survey robocalls, but these calls carried a sales pitch for a cruise, and that made them sales calls.
How It Ended
In 2015, CCL got a $7.73 million civil penalty, partially suspended after it paid $500,000, and had to monitor its lead generators. Linked Service Solutions and its owners got $5 million, suspended upon payment of $25,000. Economic Strategy and deJongh got $295,000, and Hamilton $750,000, each suspended after a $2,000 payment. In February 2017, Accuardi and his companies were barred from robocalling, with a $1.35 million judgment suspended after they paid $2,500.
My Takeaway
If you are buying transfers, ask what the original call says. A "survey" that includes a free cruise at the end is a sales call and the buyer ends up named in the complaint.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/122-3196-x150028-caribbean-cruise-line-inc
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2015/03/ftc-ten-state-attorneys-general-take-action-against-political-survey-robocallers-pitching-cruise
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2017/02/ftc-states-put-remaining-defendants-massive-caribbean-cruise-lines-robocall-operation-permanent-dry
- The March 2015 joint complaint by the FTC and ten states against Caribbean Cruise Line, its lead generators, and the telecom companies that assisted them.
