Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Free Dinner, No Pitch: Seventh Circuit Says Elanco's Vet Seminar Faxes Weren't Ads
Who doesn't love a free dinner?
On this page
Elanco Animal Health faxed a veterinary hospital two invitations to a free dinner program with continuing education credits offered. The hospital sued, saying the dinners were just a sneaky way to sell Elanco products.
The Seventh Circuit said: show me the ad. And there wasn't one.
So what happened?
Elanco is an animal health products and services company. It sent Ambassador Animal Hospital, Ltd. two unsolicited faxes inviting its vets and owner to RSVP for dinner programs. One was titled "Canine and Feline Disease Prevention Hot Topics." The other was "Rethinking Management of Osteoarthritis." Both had continuing education approval, named the presenters and carried the Elanco logo.
Ambassador filed a putative class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) against Elanco and its parent, Eli Lilly & Co. It argued the dinners were a ploy: the topics overlapped with Elanco products, and sales managers handled the RSVPs. The district court dismissed with prejudice.
The ruling
In Ambassador Animal Hospital, Ltd. v. Elanco Animal Health Inc., No. 22-1304, 74 F.4th 829 (7th Cir. July 24, 2023), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit affirmed. Judge Kirsch wrote the opinion.
The TCPA bans faxing an "unsolicited advertisement," meaning material "advertising the commercial availability or quality of any property, goods, or services." 47 U.S.C. § 227(a)(5).
Here's the thing ... the court said that definition is about what the fax says, not why it was sent.
- The fax has to do the advertising. It must indicate "directly or indirectly" to a reasonable recipient that the sender is promoting or selling something.
- A logo and related topics aren't enough. Companies can fax invitations to free education on company letterhead.
- No pretext theory. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) said in 2006 that "free" seminars are often a pretext for ads. The court held that part of the order conflicts with the statute and gets no deference.
The Third Circuit’s free opioid seminar fax decision
But the court gave a road map for what would cross the line. Something like "Join us for a free dinner discussion of how Alenza can help manage canine inflammation." Naming the product makes it an ad.
Why should you care?
Look, this is a Seventh Circuit rule. A year later, the Fourth Circuit let a similar claim proceed against a company that faxed doctors an invitation to a free coding webinar. It said both courts were applying the same test to different facts. So where you send matters.
Read that again. Same kind of fax, different results.
What to do this week
- Don't fax event invites without permission. That's the simple fix.
- If you do, keep them educational. No product names, no pitch.
- Remember the RSVP funnel. If signing up triggers marketing, some courts will call it an ad.
- Include an opt-out notice on anything that could be read as promotional.
It's not rocket science. If you want to sell, get consent first. That's it.
Read the Seventh Circuit's opinion in Ambassador Animal Hospital v. Elanco.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Ambassador Animal Hospital, Ltd. v. Elanco Animal Health Inc., No. 22-1304 (7th Cir. decided July 24, 2023)
- Opinion, Ambassador Animal Hospital, Ltd. v. Elanco Animal Health Inc., No. 22-1304 (7th Cir. decided July 24, 2023) (2)
- Opinion, Ambassador Animal Hospital, Ltd. v. Elanco Animal Health Inc., No. 22-1304 (7th Cir. decided July 24, 2023).
