Case analysis · State telemarketing laws
Dobronski v. Tobias & Associates: Twelve Identical Robocalls, a Callback, and a Call-by-Call Scorecard
Dobronski v. Tobias & Associates, Inc., No. 23-10331 (E.D. Mich. Mar. 7, 2025) takes a call by call, statute by statute approach and provides a handy scorecard. Judge Judith E. Levy largely denied motions to dismiss filed by an insurance marketing organization, its affiliated agents and two life insurers, but trimmed several claims along the way.
On this page
The Calls
The plaintiff, representing himself, received thirteen calls between April 2022 and February 2023. Calls 1 through 12 all opened the same way: a few seconds of silence, then an identical prerecorded pitch from "American Benefits" for final expense insurance. Calls 1 through 11 cut off mid-qualification. On Call 12 he made it through and reached a licensed agent with "The Enrollment Center," who pitched policies from both insurers. The line dropped and then the agent called back eleven minutes later (Call 13). Applications from both insurers then arrived by email, prefilled with the fake "canary trap" name the plaintiff had given.
Same Recording, Same Caller (Plausibly)
The defendants said nothing tied Calls 1 through 11 to them. The court disagreed, finding that identical recordings, allegations that lead generators may use generic names and spoofed numbers plausibly tie all twelve calls. The insurers argued the "American Benefits" name had been used to pitch other companies' products in the plaintiff's separate Family First Life case, but those calls involved live agents, not this recording. Recycled scripts were possible but that is not an obvious enough alternative to defeat the claim.
VanderSloot on tying fictitious caller names to a lead generator
Call 13: One Call or Two?
- Federal Do Not Call claim: survives. Playing along with the pitch ("feigned interest") is not consent, and no signed written agreement was alleged.
- Identification rule for prerecorded calls (47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(d)(4)): dismissed for Call 13, which was a live call.
- Michigan Home Solicitation Sales Act: dismissed for Call 13, because Calls 12 and 13 were one continuous "solicitation" given the accidental drop.
- Florida Telephone Solicitation Act (FTSA): survives for Call 13 on the "immediately" identify yourself rule, since the agent named his business only when asked.
Florida's Reach
The FTSA reaches calls to people in Florida or made from Florida. The plaintiff wasn't alleged to be in Florida, and nothing showed the call centers, alleged to be overseas, dialed from Florida, so the FTSA claims for Calls 1 through 12 were dismissed. Call 13 came from an agent who said he was in Florida, on a Florida area code, so it stays. Standing for the FTSA claim was fine under Drazen v. Pinto.
Agency and Michigan Law
The court found vicarious liability plausibly pleaded against the marketing organization, its executive and two individual agents, and both insurers. The insurers emailed applications mid-call. Sending applications counts as a possible benefit, and a "cancelled to edit" email didn't settle whether one insurer actually rejected the application. The agent who took Call 12 is off the hook for Calls 1 through 11.
The Michigan caller identification claim survived even though the plaintiff alleged both Michigan area codes and overseas call centers. Rule 8 allows for inconsistent pleadings.
Willfulness
Calls to a registered number plausibly support treble damages for Calls 1 through 12, but not the callback which the court treated as a non-willful response to the plaintiff's own engagement on Call 12.
Takeaways
- Identical recordings connect anonymous calls.
- State laws count calls differently. Two calls minutes apart can be one solicitation under Michigan law, and two calls under federal law.
- Insurers who mail applications risk ratification.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
