Case analysis · Litigation & decisions

189 Calls to an 11-Year-Old: Ninth Circuit Says the Intended Recipient's Consent Doesn't Count

Here's a nightmare for any company that calls customers.

By Adam YoungPublished 2 min read
On this page

Credit One Bank's vendors called a cellular number 189 times during four months trying to collect from a cardholder. Problem is, the number had been reassigned. The person picking up was an eleven-year-old boy.

In N.L. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., Nos. 19-15399 and 19-15938, 960 F.3d 1164 (9th Cir. June 3, 2020), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed a $94,500 jury verdict against the bank. Judge Bress wrote it for a panel with Judges Gould and Christen.

So what happened?

A Credit One customer, D.V., gave consent in 2014 to be called at a number ending in -9847. About two years later, without Credit One knowing, the number was reassigned to Sandra Lemos. She let her son N.L. use it as his phone.

When D.V. became delinquent, three vendors began calling the number. Some days N.L. would receive eight calls before noon. Once, two calls came within a minute of each other.

N.L. sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The jury awarded $500 for each of the 189 calls.

Credit One's argument

Credit One said: we had consent from the guy we meant to call. That should be enough. Or at least, we had a good-faith belief we had consent.

The district court instructed the jury that the law requires consent from the current subscriber or the customary user of the phone. "Consent from the intended recipient of the call... is not sufficient."

What the Ninth Circuit said

Here's the thing ... the TCPA exempts calls made with "the prior express consent of the called party." Nowhere does it say "intended recipient."

Wilson v. Skopos Financial on consent from the wrong person

The court walked through every use of "called party" in the statute:

  • It's the person you actually called. As the Seventh Circuit put it, if Smith dials Jones but reaches Perkins by mistake, nobody would call Jones the "called party."
  • The "called party" gets charged for the call. Only the current subscriber pays. Not the old customer.
  • Other sections fit too. The rule about releasing "the called party's line" when they hang up only makes sense for the person who actually answered.

Credit One also leaned on Federal Communications Commission (FCC) safe harbors for reassigned numbers. The court said those cut the other way. If intent were enough, why would anyone need a safe harbor?

And the court pointed out the obvious: the vendors called a kid almost 200 times before figuring out he wasn't the debtor.

Read that again. Almost 200 times.

The autodialer side note

Credit One also challenged the jury's autodialer definition, which followed Marks v. Crunch San Diego. The panel was bound by Marks. Less than a year later, the Supreme Court rejected Marks' broad reading in Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid. But the "called party" holding is still good law in the Ninth Circuit.

Why should you care?

Look, numbers get reassigned all the time. Your old consent doesn't follow the number to a new person.

What to do this week

  • Use the FCC's Reassigned Numbers Database before calling or texting old consents.
  • Listen when someone says "wrong number." Then actually stop.
  • Watch your vendors. Credit One was held responsible for calls its vendors placed.
  • Cap call frequency. Eight calls before noon is a jury exhibit waiting to happen.

Old consent isn't a permission slip forever. Check the number.

Read the Ninth Circuit's opinion in N.L. v. Credit One Bank.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Opinion, N.L. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., Nos. 19-15399 and 19-15938 (9th Cir. filed June 3, 2020)
  2. Opinion, N.L. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., Nos. 19-15399 and 19-15938 (9th Cir. filed June 3, 2020) (2)
  3. Opinion, N.L. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., Nos. 19-15399 and 19-15938 (9th Cir. filed June 3, 2020).
Adam Young, CEO of Ringba, Miami, Florida

About the Author: Adam Young

Adam Young is a 42-year-old entrepreneur from Miami, Florida. He is the CEO of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform. Adam Young has been in telecom, call routing and performance marketing for over a decade, and is the author of The Pay Per Call Revolution. At TCPA.com, Adam Young writes about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), robocall enforcement, tech support fraud cases and what actions by the Department of Justice (DOJ), Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mean for companies that make calls. His goal is to help companies stay compliant and keep scammers off the phone network.

More from Adam Young

Topics