Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
The Verification Call That Cost $7 Million: United States v. Prochnow
Verification calls are supposed to be the boring, safe part of a sale. You read a script and confirm the order. In this magazine telemarketing case, the verification calls were where the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) said the trouble happened, and the owner ended up owing more than $7 million.
On this page
The Setup
Richard L. Prochnow of Atlanta founded a telemarketing company, Direct Sales International (DSI), in 1995. According to the Eleventh Circuit's opinion, DSI worked with "lead broker" groups that sold magazine package subscriptions. After a broker made a sale, a DSI employee called the customer to verify it with a standardized script.
In December 1996, Prochnow signed a consent decree with the FTC. Among other things, it barred quoting a weekly price unless the customer could actually pay weekly, and required telling customers the cost of each magazine and the total cost of the package.
What Went Wrong
The Eleventh Circuit opinion lays out what the district court found:
- DSI's verifiers kept quoting weekly rates, then called the package price its "total value" instead of its total cost.
- In 1998 and 1999, agents continued to fail to supply the price of each individual magazine.
- Customers were told that DSI had to prepay publishers, which was not the case in most instances.
- Starting in 1998, verifiers pitched a "no obligation" 30-day buying club trial at the end of the call. They didn't say enrollment was automatic unless the customer canceled, that a full year would be charged when the trial ended, or give the club's phone number.
- The typical verification call was made by someone who spoke too fast to allow a person of average intelligence to follow.
- About 70% of verified sales were canceled or went into collection between the second and third months.
- People who tried to cancel got new sales pitches.
The Case
The United States, on behalf of the FTC, sued in April 2002 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia, alleging violations of the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) and the 1996 decree. After a nine-day hearing, the court found Prochnow violated both.
Here's a detail worth noticing. The court believed Prochnow didn't personally know the upsell disclosures were missing. But because he controlled DSI's operations, it found he should have known, and imputed that knowledge to him.
The Penalty
The district court assessed $5,455,280 in civil penalties and ordered $1,685,000 in disgorgement. It counted only 1998 and 1999 to give him credit for compliance efforts in 1997. The penalty worked out to $7,472 per day of violation, less than the $10,000 per day maximum at the time.
The court also forbade Prochnow from owning, controlling, managing, advising, or assisting a telemarketing business for five years, with a few narrow exceptions. The Eleventh Circuit affirmed on October 22, 2007.
Separately, the magazine telemarketers Cross Media Marketing Corp. and Media Outsourcing, Inc. settled with the FTC and the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) in 2003. That deal required recording entire calls with consumers who signed up.
The Takeaway
Your verification script is a sales script, and this court treated it that way. If it hides the total price or slides in a free trial without the terms, "it was just verification" won't save you. And if you run the place, "I didn't know" may not either.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/x020054-prochnow-richard-l-individually-dba-direct-sales-international-et-al
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2007/11/court-affirms-ruling-magazine-seller-will-pay-more-7-million
- The Eleventh Circuit's October 2007 opinion affirming the civil penalties and disgorgement against Richard L. Prochnow.
