Analysis · Litigation & decisions
The Charity That Signed Off on the Script: Disabled Police and Sheriffs Foundation
Usually when we talk about telemarketing cases, the defendant is the company dialing the phones. This one flips it. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Missouri Attorney General (AG) went after the "charity" itself, saying it helped its fundraisers deceive donors over the phone.
On this page
The Players
On March 27, 2019, the FTC and the State of Missouri, through AG Eric Schmitt, filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri (Case No. 4:19-cv-00667). The defendants were Disabled Police and Sheriffs Foundation, Inc. (DPSF), which also did business as The American Police and Sheriffs Association and Police Officers Safety Association, and its founder and Executive Director, David Kenik. The complaint described Kenik as DPSF's sole employee.
The Numbers Are Rough
According to the complaint, DPSF collected more than $9.9 million through telemarketing and direct mail nationwide from 2013 through 2017. Here's where it went, per the complaint:
- DPSF hired two fundraisers, Outreach Calling and Charitable Resource Foundation, to solicit mainly by phone. Outreach Calling got 90 cents of every dollar it collected. Charitable Resource Foundation got 88 cents.
- In 2015, almost 95% of the money went to Kenik and the fundraisers.
- For helping disabled officers, DPSF spent just 0.65 cents per donated dollar in 2015.
- From 2013 through 2016, it spent $60,000 total helping 25 families of slain officers. In 2015, when donors gave more than $1.5 million, three families received a total of $6,000.
Meanwhile the pitch focused on the heroism of the officers, including the statement that "an officer is killed in the line of duty every other day in our country."
Why the Charity Was on the Hook Under the TSR
The FTC stated that Kenik negotiated the fundraiser contracts and approved the telemarketing scripts, pledge letters and other materials. That's the key.
The Outreach Calling fundraiser case
The Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) has an "assisting and facilitating" provision. It makes it a violation to give substantial assistance or support to a telemarketer while knowing, or consciously avoiding knowing, that the telemarketer is breaking the TSR. The FTC and Missouri said DPSF and Kenik did exactly that by supporting telemarketers who misrepresented how donations would be used.
Missouri's AG could bring that TSR count because the Telemarketing Act lets state AGs sue in federal court over TSR violations. Missouri also added claims under its Merchandising Practices Act.
How It Ended
A stipulated order entered April 30, 2019, bans DPSF and Kenik from soliciting charitable contributions. It imposes a $9,932,323 judgment, and all but $100,000 is suspended because of inability to pay. The FTC said the money paid would go to one or more legitimate charities that actually help disabled police and sheriffs, as recommended by Missouri and approved by the court.
Takeaway
If you're the client and you approve the script, you aren't just a bystander. Signing off on claims you know are false can make you liable even if someone else dials. Know what your callers are saying in your name.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/172-3128-disabled-police-sheriffs-foundation-inc
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/03/ftc-states-continue-fight-against-sham-charities-shut-down-operations-falsely-claimed-help-disabled
- The March 2019 complaint filed by the FTC and the State of Missouri against DPSF and David Kenik.
