Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Teltech Systems v. Bryant: Congress Protected Harmless Spoofing, So Mississippi Couldn't Ban It
Spoofing gets a bad rap, and usually for good reason. But in Teltech Systems, Inc. v. Bryant, 702 F.3d 232 (5th Cir. 2012), the Fifth Circuit held that Congress deliberately left some spoofing alone, and that a state law banning more of it than federal law does was preempted.
On this page
Judge Rhesa Hawkins Barksdale wrote for a panel that also included Judges King and Smith.
What Is Spoofing, Anyway?
The court defined spoofing as misrepresenting the caller identification (caller ID) information that is shown to the person receiving a call. The court said the practice "has both improper and legitimate applications."
The plaintiffs were two companies that offered spoofing services throughout the country. One had a calling card product that allowed its customers to change the caller ID that the called party sees. The other used spoofing for "mystery shopping," where its representatives posed as customers to test clients' customer service departments.
Two Laws, Two Different Intent Standards
In early 2010, Mississippi passed its Caller ID Anti-Spoofing Act. It prohibited entering false caller ID information "with the intent to deceive, defraud or mislead the recipient of a call," and made it a misdemeanor.
Later that year, Congress amended the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) with the Truth in Caller ID Act of 2009. The federal law makes it unlawful to knowingly transmit misleading or inaccurate caller ID information "with the intent to defraud, cause harm, or wrongfully obtain anything of value."
FCC Imposes $120 Million Penalty on Adrian Abramovich for 96 Million Spoofed Robocalls
See the difference? Spoofing that is intended to defraud or harm violates both laws. Spoofing meant only to "deceive" or "mislead," without intent to cause harm, violated only Mississippi's law.
The district court struck down the Mississippi law under the dormant Commerce Clause. The Fifth Circuit affirmed the result, but for a different reason: conflict preemption.
Why the State Law Lost
The court began with a presumption against preemption, since the Mississippi law was based on consumer protection, an area traditionally left to the states. It noted that the TCPA's exemption of the caller ID provision from its savings clause was "arguably unclear," so it did not decide express preemption.
But the history of the federal law was telling:
- Two bills, one choice. A House bill would have banned spoofing with intent to "defraud or deceive." The Senate's narrower language, the version that passed, required intent to defraud, cause harm, or wrongfully obtain something of value.
- Legitimate uses. A Senate report noted the importance of spoofing for domestic violence victims and for individuals wishing to provide a temporary callback number.
- Floor statements. House members said they drafted the bill to prohibit only harmful spoofing and to protect legitimate practices.
- The Federal Communications Commission agreed. Its implementing order said that Congress balanced the drawbacks of malicious spoofing against the benefits of legitimate spoofing.
Comparing Arizona v. United States (2012), the court held that protecting non-harmful spoofing was a federal objective. Mississippi's ban on it was an obstacle to that objective and was preempted. Since preemption decided the case, the court did not reach the Commerce Clause or First Amendment questions, and it vacated the district court's Commerce Clause holding.
What I Take From It
- Intent is everything. Under the federal statute, harmful intent is what makes spoofing illegal.
- States can't simply go further here. At least in the Fifth Circuit, a state law reaching spoofing without harmful intent conflicts with federal law.
- Fraudulent spoofing is still out. Nothing in this ruling protects spoofing that is intended to defraud, cause harm, or wrongfully obtain something of value.
Read the Fifth Circuit's opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
