Analysis · Litigation & decisions
"Sweepstakes Security Commission": Costa Rica Sweepstakes Call Center Defendants Get Up to 50 Years, and a Texas List Broker Goes to Prison Too
This 2009 group of federal cases is notable for one sentencing detail: a Texas-based list broker was sentenced alongside the call center owners. The calls came from Costa Rica over the internet, disguised where they were coming from, and claimed to be from a "Sweepstakes Security Commission."
On this page
The June 2009 sentencings
On June 2, 2009, the Department of Justice (DOJ) Criminal Division announced that U.S. District Court Judge Frank D. Whitney of the Western District of North Carolina sentenced:
- Michael Kearns, 33, of Sacramento: nine years
- Herman Kankrini, 44, of Montreal: 87 months, with $10 million in restitution owed jointly and severally
- Severin Marcel Stone, 32, of Los Angeles: 90 months
DOJ described the three as the owner of one Costa Rica call center and two employees of another. Kearns and Stone owed $5 million jointly and severally. DOJ said grand juries in Charlotte and Asheville had charged 46 defendants. It also noted that on Sept. 24, 2008, telemarketing room owner Giuseppe Pileggi, 48, of Montreal, was sentenced to 50 years and ordered to forfeit $8.3 million in the scheme.
Seven Years for the Shell Account Guy Behind a Costa Rica Sweepstakes Call Center
The September 2009 sentencings
On September 23, 2009, DOJ announced that Judge Whitney had sentenced four Costa Rica call center owners, one employee and a Texas-based list broker. By then, 39 defendants had been convicted. The sentences were:
- Michael Mangarella, 49, of Brooklyn: 50 years, $10 million forfeiture (convicted at trial in September 2008)
- Michal Zakrzewski, 42, of Montreal: 126 months
- Antonio Carl Testore, 54, of Montreal: 97 months, $1.5 million forfeiture
- Martin Kalchstein, 63, of Brooklyn: six years
- Jaime Ligator, 68, of Miami: five years, $2.6 million forfeiture
- Trent Nyfeller, 44, of Dallas: 41 months
Every defendant except Kalchstein owed $4,291,473 in restitution jointly and severally. Kalchstein had already been convicted in the scheme and sentenced to 90 months. Kalchstein had fled to Mexico, instead of going to prison, and pleaded guilty to failure to report and obstruction of justice.
DOJ's release did not say which defendant was the list broker.
How the calls worked
According to court documents, as described by DOJ:
- Calls were made from Costa Rica using Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP), with computers placing calls over the internet, which disguised where the calls came from.
- Callers said they were from the "Sweepstakes Security Commission."
- Victims, mostly over 55, were told they had won a large prize but had to wire thousands of dollars to Costa Rica for a "refundable insurance fee."
- As long as victims kept paying, the callers kept asking for more.
The U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS), the Department of Commerce Office of the Inspector General and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) investigated, with Costa Rican authorities part of the task force.
The bottom line:
An early wave of Costa Rica sweepstakes call center prosecutions in North Carolina produced 50-year sentences and a prison term for a Texas-based list broker. The calls were made over VoIP to hide their origin and used a made-up "Sweepstakes Security Commission."
Key takeaways
- VoIP masking was central to the scheme.
- A list broker was sentenced alongside the callers.
- Fake official-sounding names were used to make the pitch sound legitimate.
- A telemarketing room owner got 50 years, as did Mangarella after trial.
- Fleeing a sentence led to new charges.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- DOJ, Office of Public Affairs, "Fraudulent Telemarketers Who Claimed U.S. Victims Won Large Sweepstakes Sentenced to Prison for Roles in Scheme" (June 2, 2009)
- DOJ, Office of Public Affairs, "Fraudulent Telemarketer Sentenced to 50 Years in Prison, Co-Conspirators Also Sentenced for Roles in Fake Sweepstakes Scheme" (Sept. 23, 2009)
