Analysis · Litigation & decisions
"Pennies on the Dollar!!" How a Health Insurance Sales Script Led to Fraud Convictions at Simple Health
Two exclamation points. In a sales script. About health insurance.
On this page
That's the line prosecutors put in the indictment.
What happened?
On February 24, 2022, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Illinois, part of the Department of Justice (DOJ), announced that a federal grand jury in East St. Louis indicted three people from a South Florida telemarketing business called Simple Health, also known as Health Benefits One:
- Steven Dorfman, 37, of Fort Lauderdale, the former owner;
- Candida L. Girouard, 45, of Valrico, the former Chief Compliance Officer; and
- John A. Sand, 47, of Fort Lauderdale, the former Vice President of Sales.
Each was charged with one count of conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud, four counts of mail fraud and eight counts of wire fraud.
The alleged scheme
Simple Health sold health insurance over the phone. Most of the policies were limited indemnity plans, which cap covered medical expenses at a fairly low amount. After that, patients pay 100% out of pocket.
The Assurance IQ and MediaAlpha health-plan settlement
According to the indictment, a deceptive script tricked people into buying those plans. Salespeople had to say things like:
- "The whole idea of this plan is to make your out of pocket expenses as low as possible . . . ."
- "When all is said and done, you end up with pennies on the dollar!!"
After buying, customers often called customer service to complain that big medical bills they thought were covered weren't, that their doctors and hospitals didn't take the plans, and that prescriptions weren't covered.
From May 4, 2012, through November 1, 2018, Simple Health sold policies to over 400,000 people and brought in more than $190,000,000, according to the indictment.
In October 2018, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) Midwest Regional Office sued Simple Health, and at the FTC's request the court appointed a receiver to take over the business.
Update: convicted
On February 14, 2024, the U.S. Attorney's Office announced that after a two-week trial, a jury convicted Dorfman, then 39, and Sand, then 49, on all 13 counts: conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud, four counts of mail fraud and eight counts of wire fraud. Evidence at trial showed commissioned salespeople also told "off-script lies." Girouard, the former Chief Compliance Officer, pleaded guilty to the conspiracy charge on November 30, 2023.
Because the scheme used telemarketing and victimized ten or more people over 55, the conspiracy count carried up to 30 years under the SCAMS Act. The U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS) led the investigation.
Here's the thing ...
Look at the titles. Owner. VP of Sales. And the Chief Compliance Officer.
Compliance people, this one's for you. Your title doesn't protect you if the script you sign off on is deceptive. If anything, it puts you right in the middle.
And health insurance is the worst place to cut corners. People find out their coverage is fake at the exact moment they need it most. In a hospital. Am I right?
What to do this week
- Read your script like a patient would. Would they understand what's covered and what's not?
- Disclose limits clearly. Caps, networks, prescriptions. Up front.
- Treat customer service complaints as compliance data.
- Compliance officers: document every concern you raise, and push back hard.
People's health is on the line. Act like it.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Department of Justice (DOJ) press release, "OWNER AND TWO TOP EXECUTIVES OF SOUTH FLORIDA HEALTH INSURANCE TELEMARKETING BUSINESS INDICTED FOR FRAUD" (Feb. 24, 2022)
- Department of Justice (DOJ) press release, "Jury Convicts Telemarketing Company Owner/CEO and Another Executive of Federal Fraud Charges for Health Insurance Policy Scheme" (Feb. 14, 2024)
