Analysis · Litigation & decisions
One Wrong Digit: The American Idol Copycat Number Case and the Pay-Per-Call Rule
Picture it. It's 2003, you're on the couch, and your favorite singer just crushed it on "American Idol." You grab the phone, dial the voting number from memory, and flip two digits. Instead of casting a vote, you hear a recording telling you to call a 900 number. You pay up to $2.97 for the privilege, and you still haven't voted.
On this page
According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), that happened to roughly 25,000 people.
What the FTC Said Happened
On March 18, 2004, the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a complaint and consent order on behalf of the FTC in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. The defendants were Utah companies Telemarketing, Inc. (also doing business as Univoxx), Apex Investments, LLC (doing business as Operator Directory Service and Northwestern Atlantic), and Universal Innovations, LLC, plus three individuals. You can read the complaint the DOJ filed yourself.
Here's the trick the FTC described. The defendants bought toll-free numbers that were very close to the real "American Idol" voting lines. Think an 800 prefix instead of 866, or two digits swapped (1-866-463-5701 instead of 1-866-436-5701). Voting only opened after the show ended, so fans had to dial from memory or scribbled notes. Misdial, and you landed on a copycat line.
Callers heard one of four recorded messages. Three of them urged callers to dial a 900 number to reach "voting lines" or "favorite contestants." The 900 number didn't connect anyone to a voting line. It just read back the real toll-free number, which the caller could have dialed for free. The customer would then have to hang up and call again.
The cost for the pay-per-call was $1.99 per call in the 2002 season and $2.97 in 2003.
Where the Pay-Per-Call Rule Comes In
The FTC's Pay-Per-Call Rule requires a "preamble" with certain disclosures when a service charges more than $2.00. Once the price jumped to $2.97, the FTC said, the defendants had to give that preamble and didn't. The complaint also said they failed to identify who was providing the service or what the service actually was, then billed callers anyway, which the FTC counted as another violation.
On a separate copycat 900 line, the FTC alleged they didn't tell callers when charges would start, or that they could avoid charges by hanging up within three seconds after the signal marking the end of the preamble.
How It Ended
The defendants settled. The consent order:
- Bans the specific "American Idol" false claims and omissions, plus similar claims for any other copycat telephone or Internet program
- Requires disclosures in any copycat plan that callers missed their intended party, who the business really is, and what the service is
- Requires the defendants to follow the Pay-Per-Call Rule, and to give certain disclosures even on calls of $2.00 or less, which the rule would normally exempt
- Imposes a $40,000 civil penalty
Why This Still Matters
Phone numbers are marketing assets, and the FTC treated using them to mislead as deception. If a number you use is built to catch someone else's callers, the people who reach you have to know right away that they didn't get who they called. And if you charge for a call, the disclosures come before the meter starts running.
This is an old case, but the lesson about phone numbers that confuse callers holds up fine.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/032-3104-telemarketing-inc-et-al-us
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2004/03/defendants-settle-ftc-charges-they-deceived-consumers-trying-vote-their-favorite-american-idol
- The complaint filed against Telemarketing, Inc. and the other defendants in March 2004.
