Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Nudge and the "Inner Circle": When the Seminar Upsell Moves to the Phone
Real estate seminars with TV stars, free hotel events, and three-day workshops don't sound like a telemarketing case. But the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and the Utah Division of Consumer Protection found the phone part, and it became a Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) count.
On this page
The Setup
In November 2019, the FTC and the Utah Division of Consumer Protection sued Nudge, LLC, Response Marketing Group, LLC, BuyPD, LLC, and their principals in the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah (Case No. 2:19-cv-00867-RJS). The complaint named owners Brandon B. Lewis, Ryan C. Poelman, Phillip W. Smith, and Shawn L. Finnegan, among others. In 2020, the FTC moved to add celebrity promoters Dean Graziosi and Scott Yancey.
According to the complaint, the defendants used reality TV personalities to draw consumers to free 90-minute "Preview Events," mostly advertised by infomercials and direct mail. Over 750,000 people attended since January 2015. The previews sold three-day Workshops, typically $1,147, and the Workshops sold pricier Advanced Training. The FTC said the scheme took in over $400 million.
Then Came the Calls
Here's where it gets interesting for us. The complaint says that during and after Advanced Training, the defendants targeted consumers with telemarketing calls to sell the "Inner Circle," a supposedly exclusive one-on-one real estate coaching program.
A few quotes from the complaint that made me cringe:
- Telemarketers could see the personal finance forms consumers filled out at the Workshops.
- Scripts told them to ask about credit card limits and savings.
- The reps claimed that information was used to see if the consumer was eligible. The FTC alleged it was really used to decide how much to charge, up to $20,000.
- Each telemarketer was tracked by "dollar per lead," the total sales from a set of leads divided by the number of leads.
The complaint also describes a history: a telemarketing floor run by one of the principals bought leads from seminar companies and sold coaching by phone before becoming part of the enterprise in 2014.
Vision Solution Marketing: Business Coaching as an "Investment Opportunity" Under the TSR
The TSR Count
The FTC and Utah filed a TSR count alleging that in telemarketing the Inner Circle, the defendants misrepresented the coaching program, such as claiming that buyers would likely earn substantial income, and made false or misleading statements to induce payment. Utah also brought claims under its Telephone Fraud Prevention Act and other state laws.
The Ending
In June 2022, the court partially granted the FTC's motion for summary judgment and found that many claims were false or misleading, including that the Inner Circle had limited slots. In May 2023 the FTC announced that the company and its principals agreed to a permanent ban on selling "wealth creation" products and services and to pay $15 million. Graziosi and Yancey agreed to pay $1.7 million. Utah called it the largest consumer protection division settlement in the state's history. In March 2024, the FTC announced that it was sending more than $10 million in refunds to 4,670 consumers.
My Takeaway
If your in-person events feed a phone sales team, those calls are telemarketing. Income claims, fake scarcity, and pricing by credit limit are not exactly what you want for a recorded line.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/182-3016-nudge-llc
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/05/ftc-suit-leads-167-million-judgment-against-principals-celebrity-endorsers-real-estate-investment
- The November 2019 complaint by the FTC and the Utah Division of Consumer Protection against Nudge, Response Marketing Group, BuyPD, and their principals (redacted public version).
