Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Moser v. Benefytt: A Personal Jurisdiction Objection to Out-of-State Class Members Is Not Waived by Omitting It From a Motion to Dismiss
In Moser v. Benefytt, Inc., No. 19-56224 (9th Cir. Aug. 10, 2021), the Ninth Circuit held that a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) defendant did not waive its objection to nationwide class certification under Bristol-Myers Squibb Co. v. Superior Court (2017) by leaving that objection out of its Rule 12 motion. Judge Bress wrote for the majority, joined by Judge Bybee. District Judge Kathleen Cardone, sitting by designation, dissented on appellate jurisdiction.
On this page
Background
A California resident sued Benefytt Technologies, Inc., formerly Health Insurance Innovations, Inc., alleging it was responsible for unwanted sales calls in violation of 47 U.S.C. ยง 227(b)(1)(A) and (B). The company is incorporated in Delaware and represents that its principal place of business is Florida. No one disputed that the court had specific personal jurisdiction over the named plaintiff's own claims.
The company moved to dismiss on other grounds, but not for lack of personal jurisdiction. When the plaintiff moved to certify two nationwide classes, it argued under Bristol-Myers that the court lacked personal jurisdiction over non-California class members' claims. In Bristol-Myers, the Supreme Court held that due process barred a California state court from exercising specific jurisdiction over nonresidents' claims in a mass action against a nonresident company.
Hood on jurisdiction where a consumer receives calls
Judge William Q. Hayes held the objection waived under Rule 12(h)(1), because Bristol-Myers was decided about a month before the company filed its Rule 12 motion, and certified both classes.
Appellate Jurisdiction Under Rule 23(f)
The majority held it could review the personal jurisdiction and waiver issues on a Rule 23(f) appeal because they went "directly to the scope of the classes" and were part of the certification order.
No Waiver
Agreeing with the Fifth Circuit (Cruson v. Jackson National Life) and the D.C. Circuit (Molock v. Whole Foods), the court held the defense was not "available" at the motion to dismiss stage:
- A defense is unavailable under Rule 12(g)(2) if its legal basis did not exist or it would have been futile.
- Putative class members are nonparties until certification. As Cruson put it, Bristol-Myers supplied new legal support, but it "did not make the objection 'available.' Certification did."
- When the court decided the Rule 12 motion, the named plaintiff was the only plaintiff, and jurisdiction over his claims was undisputed. There was nothing to dismiss.
- It could have moved to strike the class allegations, but was not required to.
The majority rejected the dissent's view that such a challenge can only be raised by a Rule 12 motion. That approach would force a court to ignore a jurisdictional problem affecting nearly the whole class at certification, then face an "inevitable" motion to dismiss afterward.
What the Court Did Not Decide
The panel did not decide whether Bristol-Myers applied to federal class actions. It vacated certification and remanded for the district court to address the objection on the merits, possibly with more record development about the company's and its alleged agents' contacts with California.
The Dissent
Judge Cardone would have held that Rule 23(f) does not confer appellate jurisdiction over a personal jurisdiction ruling, which she viewed as distinct from the Rule 23 criteria.
Practical Points
- Defendants: in the Ninth Circuit, a jurisdictional objection to nonresident class members can be raised at certification.
- Agent networks matter. On remand, contacts of the company's alleged calling agents could shape the analysis.
Read the Ninth Circuit opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
