Case analysis · Consent & revocation

Mitchell v. Toyota of Dallas: Reconsent Through Dealership Contacts Defeats a Class of Opted-Out Text Recipients

Classes built around texts sent after an opt out appear to rest on clean records: a STOP reply, a confirmation and later messages. In Mitchell v. Toyota of Dallas, No. 3:23-CV-1278-N (N.D. Tex. Oct. 28, 2025), Senior Judge David C. Godbey denied certification anyway, finding that the many ways a dealership's customers could have renewed consent would require individual inquiries.

By Harrison GevirtzPublished 2 min read
On this page

Allegations

The plaintiff bought a used car from the dealership in 2018 and began receiving marketing texts. He opted out in January 2020 and received a confirmation that he was unsubscribed. In 2021 he received a text asking whether texting was "the most convenient way" to reach him, and he alleged that, despite opting out twice, marketing messages continued through 2023. He alleged the dealership sent 16,546 texts to 1,539 customers who had opted out, in violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).

He proposed a nationwide class and a Texas class of people who received more than one marketing text within twelve months, more than 31 days after opting out, where at least one message contained one of three phrases, including the "convenient way" and "request to send a text message" language.

The Plaintiff's Method

Opted-out numbers went on the dealership's internal do-not-call list. The plaintiff's expert proposed to identify class members by matching message logs against that list, which the plaintiff argued would provide class-wide proof and avoid mini trials.

Why Certification Failed

The court did not reach Rule 23(a). It held that the class failed both Rule 23(b)(3) predominance, under the Fifth Circuit's framework in Gene & Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, and Rule 23(b)(2) cohesiveness.

Many ways to reconsent. The dealership showed that customers could have renewed consent through inbound calls, dealership visits and third party car shopping platforms. The plaintiff's method did not account for any of these.

Schweitzer on partial revocation of consent

The sample. The dealership's expert sampled 309 class numbers and found at least 256 with activity in the dealership's internal work notes, suggesting the customer may have reengaged or consented, may be a business number outside the TCPA's residential protections, or may otherwise fall outside the class.

Business numbers. The plaintiff's method had no reliable way to separate business numbers from consumer numbers.

The narrowed definition did not help. In reply, the plaintiff limited the class to consumers without a signed written agreement reconsenting to messages, drawing on the written agreement requirement in 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(c)(2)(ii). Even assuming that change captured the right consumers, the method still could not separate business numbers, so individual issues still predominated and the class was not cohesive.

Observations

  • The internal list is only a starting point. A record that a customer opted out does not prove the customer stayed opted out, particularly where the business has ongoing in-person and online contact with its customers.
  • Defense sampling is effective. A defendant's sample showing reengagement among most sampled numbers can be decisive.
  • Business versus residential status is a separate obstacle. Even a narrowed consent definition left the business number issue unresolved.
  • Fix the method, not just the definition. Narrowing the class on reply did not cure a methodology that still could not sort the numbers.

Read the Northern District of Texas memorandum opinion.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Memorandum Opinion and Order, Mitchell v. Toyota of Dallas, No. 3:23-CV-1278-N (N.D. Tex. Oct. 28, 2025)
  2. Gene & Gene, LLC v. Biopay, LLC, 541 F.3d 318 (5th Cir. 2008)
  3. Memorandum Opinion and Order, Mitchell v. Toyota of Dallas (N.D. Tex. Oct. 28, 2025).
Harrison Gevirtz, Chief Strategy Officer of Ringba, Las Vegas, Nevada

About the Author: Harrison Gevirtz

Harrison Gevirtz serves as the Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform, and is based in Las Vegas, Nevada. Harrison Gevirtz is a serial operator in call tracking, call routing and telemarketing operations, and for the past several years he has focused on how federal regulations affect the daily operations of these industries. At TCPA.com, Harrison Gevirtz covers TCPA litigation, Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) enforcement, tech support fraud prosecutions and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulemaking in a way that's accessible to the non-lawyer executive or compliance manager.

More from Harrison Gevirtz

Topics