Analysis · Autodialers & artificial voice
League of Women Voters v. Kramer: Calling Platforms Behind the AI-Generated Biden Robocalls Must Face Voting Rights and Robocall Claims
In League of Women Voters of New Hampshire v. Kramer, No. 24-cv-73-SM-TSM (D.N.H. Mar. 26, 2025), Judge Steven J. McAuliffe denied a motion to dismiss filed by two calling-platform companies, Voice Broadcasting Corporation and Life Corporation. Their services allegedly carried AI-generated robocalls imitating President Biden's voice before New Hampshire's January 2024 primary. We previously covered the Department of Justice's statement of interest in this case on the Voting Rights Act. This order goes further: it addresses standing, the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and the claims against the platforms themselves.
On this page
Background
According to the amended complaint and stipulated facts, a political consultant (now in default) commissioned an AI-generated message urging voters to "save your vote for the November election." He arranged for Voice Broadcasting to send it to about 25,000 numbers with caller ID spoofed to show the personal number of a former state party official. At Voice Broadcasting's suggestion, a final sentence was added telling recipients to call that spoofed number to opt out. Voice Broadcasting used Life Corp.'s services and equipment. Nearly 10,000 calls went to New Hampshire voters. Three voters who got the call on their home landlines, along with the League of Women Voters, sued under Section 11(b) of the Voting Rights Act, the TCPA and two New Hampshire election statutes, which also survived.
AI Political Robocalls Without Consent? FCC Commissioner Gomez Takes a Strong Position
Standing
Each individual plaintiff recognized the call as fake and voted anyway. The court held that this did not defeat standing. Section 11(b) bars attempts to intimidate, threaten or coerce, and "clumsy and unsuccessful" attempts are still attempts. Receiving a call that violated the TCPA was also a concrete injury.
The League's standing was "a much closer call" after the Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Food and Drug Administration v. Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine. The court distinguished that case because the League was not challenging a government policy. It alleged private, unlawful conduct that interfered with its core voter counseling and anti-suppression work, which forced it to divert staff and money.
Voting Rights Act
The defendants called the message "misinformation," not intimidation. The court disagreed: suggesting that a primary vote would dilute a November vote and undermine the incumbent was plausibly an attempt to suppress voting. The opt-out sentence the platform suggested undercut its claim that it knew nothing of the content.
TCPA: Who "Initiates" a Call
The TCPA prohibits initiating prerecorded calls to residential lines without consent. For purposes of the motion, the court assumed the platforms did not initiate calls. That did not end the inquiry. Under Federal Communications Commission (FCC) guidance, a platform can be liable if it was "so involved" in placing the calls, or if it knowingly allowed its platform to be used for unlawful purposes. Allegations that Voice Broadcasting knew the message, offered caller ID spoofing and recommended the opt-out sentence, with Life Corp. supplying the calling capability, were enough at this stage.
The Political Call Exemption
The platforms relied on an FCC consumer guide saying political prerecorded calls to landlines are allowed without consent. The court did not decide if the calls qualified. Even exempt calls must include an automated opt-out mechanism, and telling people to call a spoofed private number "plainly fails" that requirement.
Observations
- Platforms are not automatically conduits. Knowledge and involvement can create TCPA exposure.
- Exemptions do not waive opt-out rules. Prerecorded messages sent under an exemption still need a compliant mechanism.
Read the District of New Hampshire order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
