Analysis · Litigation & decisions
"Just Verifying Your Listing": The Montreal Yellow Pages Scam That Billed Churches
You know that call. "Hi, I'm just confirming your business address for your directory listing." Sounds harmless, right? According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), for one Montreal operation that little "verification" call was the whole scam.
On this page
The Setup
In November 2013, the FTC sued Modern Technology Inc. (doing business as Online Local Yellow Pages) and 14 other companies in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois (Case No. 13cv8257), along with three individuals: Mohamad Khaled Kaddoura, Derek Cessford, and Aaron Kirby. A judge temporarily halted the operation and froze its assets.
The FTC said the defendants operated from Montreal and used corporate shells and U.S. mail drops to hide where they really were. They went after small businesses and churches across the United States, and the FTC said they took more than $14 million. The scheme generated more than 13,000 complaints.
How the Calls Worked
Here's the play the FTC described:
- They called pretending to verify contact information to update or confirm an existing directory listing.
- Sometimes they claimed to be calling about a cancellation request and asked to verify contact information to confirm the cancellation.
- They had no prior relationship with the people they called.
Then came the bills. They averaged $499.99 or more and carried a "walking fingers" image often associated with a local yellow pages directory. Some people paid because they figured someone in their office had ordered the listing.
"Yellow Pages" Cold Calls and Fake Invoices: 30 Months After Extradition From Greece
The ones who pushed back got the recording treatment. According to the FTC complaint, the defendants used partially recorded phone conversations, where someone had verified contact information, to argue there was a binding oral contract.
Still not paying? Then came collection calls and dunning notices, often with added interest, late fees, and legal fees, plus threats of collection referrals, credit damage, and lawsuits. The defendants even created two "debt collection" companies, CC Recovery and M&A Recovery, so it looked like third parties were involved.
The FTC charged violations of the FTC Act for misrepresenting a preexisting business relationship, that consumers had agreed to buy listings, and that consumers owed money.
How It Ended
In July 2014, the court entered a default judgment that:
- Permanently banned the defendants from selling business directories or directory listings in any format
- Barred misrepresentations about preexisting relationships, purchase agreements, and amounts owed
- Barred them from collecting payment for any business directory listing
- Entered a judgment of $15,654,282.98
In December 2015, the FTC announced it was mailing 774 checks totaling more than $444,000. The FTC said each check covered the full amount the recipient paid, with an average of $574.66.
The Takeaway for Callers
A "verification" call is not a sale. If your script gets someone to confirm an address and you later treat that as a yes, you're in the territory the FTC called deception here. And recordings help you only if they show a real agreement, not a snippet of somebody reading back their zip code.
Also worth knowing: this case was brought under the FTC Act alone. Even calls to businesses can get you in trouble when the pitch is a lie.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/132-3144-modern-technology-inc-also-dba-online-local-yellow-pages-et-al
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2013/11/ftc-stops-online-yellow-pages-scam-canada-based-operation-targeted-small-businesses-churches-united
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2015/12/ftc-returns-money-consumers-conned-paying-business-directory-listings
- The FTC's November 2013 complaint against Modern Technology Inc. and the other Online Local Yellow Pages defendants.
