Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Gym Memberships and Cell Phone Plans as "Family": The FTC Case Against Ameritech Financial
Every once in a while a complaint quotes a sales call so wild you have to read it twice. This is one of those.
On this page
In February 2018, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sued a student loan debt relief operation run by Brandon Frere. In one recorded call, according to the complaint, a sales rep was explaining how to count "family size" on a government repayment application. The rep told the consumer that if someone is on "your cell phone plan" or "your gym membership," they're "considered part of your family."
That's not how it works. And it was just one piece of a much bigger case.
So what happened?
The FTC sued American Financial Benefits Center (also doing business as AFB and AF Student Services), Ameritech Financial, Financial Education Benefits Center and Frere in federal court in the Northern District of California (case no. 4:18-cv-00806). It was the eighth action in "Operation Game of Loans," the first federal and state crackdown on student loan debt relief scams.
According to the FTC:
- It started with personalized mailers claiming people qualified for federal programs that would permanently lock in a low payment or forgive their loans entirely.
- Up to $800 in illegal upfront fees to supposedly enroll people in a federal program.
- Another $100 to $1,300 for a "financial education" program.
- Then $49 to $99 a month for the life of the loan, typically 10 to 25 years. The "benefits" included things like "Key Ring & Luggage Protection" and "Everyday Grocery Savings."
- People thought those monthly payments went to their loans. None of it did. Some balances actually grew with interest.
- Refunds were often refused or much smaller than what people paid.
The FTC said the operation took more than $28 million and charged violations of the FTC Act and the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR).
Read the FTC's complaint against American Financial Benefits Center and Ameritech Financial.
How did it end?
It ended badly for Frere.
- December 2018: The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) filed criminal charges.
- December 2019: Frere pleaded guilty to two counts of wire and mail fraud.
- July 2020: He was sentenced to 42 months in prison, ordered to read all the victim impact statements and ordered to forfeit assets worth over $8.9 million.
- October 2020: He and his companies settled with the FTC. They're banned from debt relief services and prohibited from violating the TSR.
- August 2023: The FTC and DOJ sent more than $9 million in refunds to 22,562 people.
Why should you care?
A couple of things.
First, this scheme started with a mailer. That doesn't take you outside the TSR. Advance fees for debt relief are still illegal, no matter how the call starts.
Second, calls get recorded. Whatever your reps say to close a deal can end up quoted in a federal complaint.
So:
- Train reps on the actual rules of whatever program you're helping with.
- Never tell people to fudge a government form.
- Don't bundle junk "memberships" that people think are loan payments.
- No advance fees. Not for debt relief.
And remember, the FTC case isn't always the end. Sometimes there's a criminal case right behind it.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- FTC case page, American Financial Benefits Center, et al.
- FTC, "FTC Charges Ameritech, Brandon Frere With Deceiving Consumers" (Feb. 2018)
- FTC, settlement announcement (Nov. 2020)
- FTC, refunds announcement (Aug. 2023)
- FTC complaint, FTC v. American Financial Benefits Center, et al., No. 4:18-cv-00806 (N.D. Cal. filed Feb. 7, 2018).
