Case analysis · Autodialers & artificial voice
Golan v. Veritas Entertainment: A "Survey" Call Can Still Be Telemarketing
In Golan v. Veritas Entertainment, LLC, No. 14-2484, 788 F.3d 814 (8th Cir. June 8, 2015), the Eighth Circuit held that a prerecorded call is telemarketing under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) if it was made to promote a product, even when the message itself never mentions that product.
On this page
What happened
In September 2012, the backers of the film Last Ounce of Courage hired a telemarketing firm to promote it. The script, recorded by Mike Huckabee, was billed as a 45-second survey about "American freedom and liberty," then praised the movie, announced its opening date and pointed listeners to the trailer. The campaign targeted 4 million residential lines and 30 million cell phones.
Foodsmart on calls offering a free dietitian
Ron and Dorit Golan, who were on federal and state do-not-call lists, didn't answer either of two calls. Their answering machine recorded only this: "Liberty. This is a public survey call. We may call back later."
The Golans filed a putative class action. On its own initiative, the Eastern District of Missouri dismissed the case, ruling that the short messages contained no advertisement or telemarketing, so the Golans had no injury, and that they were inadequate class representatives because most class members heard the full pitch.
What the court held
Judge Murphy wrote for the panel.
Standing. Congress can create legal rights whose invasion is an injury. The TCPA bars prerecorded calls to homes without consent, so the question was whether the Golans alleged a violation.
Advertisement vs. telemarketing. The court agreed the two messages weren't advertisements, since they mentioned no goods or services. But telemarketing turns on purpose, not content. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations define it as initiating a call "for the purpose of encouraging the purchase" of goods or services. Content can be "instructive," but it isn't "dispositive."
The court pointed to Congress's finding that consumers view prerecorded calls as a nuisance "regardless of the content." The intrusion into the home is the same whether or not the pitch gets delivered. Here, the context made clear the whole campaign was designed to sell movie tickets. So the calls were telemarketing, even though the voicemails never named the film.
Class representatives. Because purpose was the key issue for everyone, the Golans didn't face a unique defense. Every call, answered or not, was made to promote the movie.
The court declined to decide whether several defendants could be vicariously liable, leaving that for the district court. It reversed and remanded.
Why this matters
You can't get around the prerecorded call rules by trimming what plays on voicemail. If the campaign exists to sell something, a "survey" label won't change that.
Practical points
- Judge every prerecorded campaign by its purpose, not just the words on the recording.
- Survey or informational framing won't help if the call is part of a sales effort.
- Get the consent the law requires before sending prerecorded calls to residential lines.
- Scrub against do-not-call lists before buying any calling list.
Read the Eighth Circuit's opinion in Golan v. Veritas Entertainment.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
