Analysis · Litigation & decisions
"Easy Targets": Buffalo-Area Debt Collection Ring Used Fake Attorneys and Arrest Threats, and Its Leader Gets 37 Months
Here's the thing about this Western New York case: the "debt collection agency" had nice names like Lakeside Mediations and Valentine Legal Mediation. On the phone, according to federal prosecutors, it threatened arrest, handed people off to staff pretending to be lawyers, and went back to people who had already paid. Internally, those people were called "easy targets."
On this page
The charges
On June 26, 2017, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Western District of New York, part of the Department of Justice (DOJ), announced a criminal complaint charging six people with conspiracy to commit wire fraud: Joseph Ciffa, Erica Lounsberry, Debbie Seright, Shauniqua Rodriguez, Damario Turpin and Carmelo Collana. A December 15, 2016 search of Ciffa's Grand Island home turned up his cell phone. A forensic analysis found recorded calls in which, according to DOJ, Ciffa described the fraud scheme in detail.
How the calls worked
According to DOJ, from about 2014 to early 2017:
- Ciffa's operation ran out of locations in Niagara Falls and Kenmore, New York, and his home office. It used names including Lakeside Mediations, Lincoln Mediation, Valentine Legal Mediation, First Point Mediation, State Filing and Legal Services, and Elite Services.
- Collectors called "debtors" across the country and threatened them, citing criminal statutes and saying criminal complaints or warrants would be filed.
- Callers used false identities. Debtors were routinely sent to employees posing as attorneys to intimidate them and get payment.
- The operation collected on debts already paid, collected again from people who had already paid (the "easy targets") and over-collected on real debts.
- Payment came by MoneyGram, wire transfer and card.
- Collana set up shell companies and payment accounts and gave collectors access to TLO, an online commercial database, to find people's addresses, employers and birth dates.
The sentences
- Carmelo Collana: 12 months; Debbie Seright, a manager whose section collected about $1,154,213: 24 months (June 17, 2019)
- Shauniqua Rodriguez, a caller and informal trainer: 12 months (July 24, 2020)
- Erica Lounsberry, a manager who trained callers and the fake attorneys: 21 months (Oct. 8, 2024). Her group collected about $2,103,105.
- Joseph Ciffa: 37 months for wire fraud conspiracy and filing a false tax return (Nov. 19, 2024). His operation collected about $3,061,205 from victims between January 2015 and December 2016. DOJ also said he committed Medicaid benefits fraud in 2016.
U.S. District Judge Richard J. Arcara imposed all of the sentences. Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), IRS Criminal Investigation (IRS-CI) and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service (USPIS) investigated, with the New York State Office of the Inspector General.
Why it matters
Every piece of this was done by phone: the threats, the fake lawyers, the repeat collections. And the manager who trained the people making the calls got prison time too.
That's it.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- DOJ, USAO Western District of New York, "Six Defendants Charged In A Debt Collection Scheme" (June 26, 2017)
- DOJ, USAO Western District of New York, "Kenmore Man And Niagara Falls Woman Sentenced For Their Roles in Debt Collection Scheme" (June 17, 2019)
- DOJ, USAO Western District of New York, "Lockport Woman Sentenced On Wire Fraud Charge For Her Role In Debt Collection Scheme" (July 24, 2020)
- DOJ, USAO Western District of New York, "Niagara Falls woman sentenced for her role in debt collection scheme" (Oct. 8, 2024)
- DOJ, USAO Western District of New York, "Leader in debt collection scheme going to prison" (Nov. 19, 2024)
