Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Court Says Back-End Providers Can Face Telemarketing Sales Rule Liability in CFPB Debt-Relief Case
The bottom line: on September 15, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Western District of New York denied several motions to dismiss in the debt-relief enforcement action brought by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and seven state attorneys general against Strategic Financial Solutions and related parties. The court held that "substantial assistance" liability under the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) does not require front-end involvement in the telemarketing.
On this page
What happened
According to the second amended complaint, as summarized by Orrick's InfoBytes, the defendants ran a debt-relief scheme that collected over $84 million in illegal advance fees from financially distressed consumers. The claims were brought under the TSR, New York Executive Law, New York General Business Law and Wisconsin law. These are allegations. The case is at the pleading stage.
The defendants who moved were affiliated litigation support companies, a consulting firm and individual attorneys. They argued that they provided only back-end services and did not take part in the telemarketing.
What the court held
The court overruled all objections to the magistrate judge's reports and recommendations and adopted them in full. Key holdings:
- No front-end requirement. The TSR "does not require the provision of 'front-end' services, or direct involvement in the alleged TSR violation." The complaint adequately alleged substantial assistance.
- A low threshold. The court declined to import a stricter aiding-and-abetting standard and described the TSR's threshold for substantial assistance as low.
- Factual knowledge is enough. The rule requires knowledge, or conscious avoidance of knowledge, of the underlying conduct. It does not require knowledge that the conduct was unlawful. The court cited the Second Circuit's ruling affirming the preliminary injunction in the same case.
- The rule stands. The court rejected the argument that the substantial assistance provision is invalid as applied to abusive telemarketing practices.
The state-law claims also survived, and the court noted that defendants may renew their arguments at summary judgment.
The law in plain English
The TSR prohibits providing substantial assistance or support to a seller or telemarketer while knowing, or consciously avoiding knowing, that the seller or telemarketer is violating the rule. The TSR also generally bans debt-relief companies that telemarket from collecting fees before they settle or change a consumer's debt.
Why it matters
Many companies assume that if they never place a call, the TSR cannot reach them. This ruling says otherwise, at least at the pleading stage. Law firms, processors, consultants and software providers who support a telemarketing operation can be named.
What this means for you
- Know your clients. If you are supporting a telemarketing business, understand how it sells and how it charges.
- Watch for advance fees. In debt relief, fees collected before results are a core TSR problem.
- Do not look away. Conscious avoidance counts as knowledge.
- Document your diligence. Records of what you checked, and when, are your best defense.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
