Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Berman v. Freedom Financial Network: Fine Print on Lead Generation Pages Did Not Bind Consumers to Arbitrate TCPA Claims
A lead generator could not force consumers to arbitrate Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) claims based on a tiny gray notice placed above a "continue" button. In Berman v. Freedom Financial Network, LLC, No. 20-16900, 30 F.4th 849 (9th Cir. Apr. 5, 2022), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of the defendants' motion to compel arbitration.
On this page
The bottom line: if a website relies on users clicking a button to accept terms, the notice must be reasonably conspicuous and must say plainly that clicking the button means agreement.
Background
Fluent, Inc. is a digital marketing company that uses gift cards and samples to entice consumers to provide their contact information and answer surveys. Plaintiffs Stephanie Hernandez and Erica Russell visited two Fluent websites. Fluent and Lead Science, LLC then allegedly used that information to place unsolicited calls and texts marketing the debt relief services of Freedom Financial Network, LLC and Freedom Debt Relief, LLC. The plaintiffs filed a putative TCPA class action.
On each page, between the form fields and a large green "Continue" button, two lines of tiny gray text stated: "I understand and agree to the Terms & Conditions which includes mandatory arbitration and Privacy Policy." The hyperlinked phrases were underlined but in the same gray font, not blue. The linked terms required arbitration of disputes about telemarketing calls or texts. The motion to compel arbitration was denied by the district court.
The decision
Judge Watford wrote the opinion, joined by Judge Hurwitz. Judge Baker of the U.S. Court of International Trade, sitting by designation, concurred.
The test. Applying principles shared by New York and California law, the court held that absent actual knowledge, an online agreement based on inquiry notice is enforceable only if (1) the website provides reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms and (2) the consumer takes an action, such as clicking a button or checking a box, that unambiguously manifests assent to those terms. The defendants did not argue actual knowledge.
Not conspicuous. The court called the notice "the antithesis of conspicuous." It was in a tiny gray font, smaller than the surrounding text and "barely legible," while the page design drew attention elsewhere. Underlining the hyperlinked terms alone did not make it readily apparent that a hyperlink existed. Customary signals include a contrasting color, typically blue, or all capital letters.
No unambiguous assent. Clicking a button does not signify agreement unless the user is explicitly told that clicking will constitute assent. The notice said "I understand and agree," but did not say what action would constitute agreement, and the button itself said nothing about terms. The court suggested language stating "By clicking the Continue >> button, you agree to the Terms & Conditions." The phrase "which includes mandatory arbitration" was irrelevant because the question was not the content of the terms but whether the consumers agreed to them at all.
McCullagh v. SmartMatch: "I Was Asleep" Sends a Free Samples Site Arbitration Fight to a Jury
Reconsideration. The court also affirmed the denial of the defendants' motion for reconsideration based on deposition testimony taken two months before the arbitration ruling, because they did not act with reasonable diligence.
The court did not consider whether the non-signatories, Freedom and Lead Science, would have had the ability to enforce the arbitration clause.
The concurrence
Judge Baker would have decided first that California law applied and then relied on recent California Court of Appeal decisions in finding that these pages were "sign-in wrap" agreements. He reached the same result.
Practical takeaways
- Put the consent and terms notice in legible text that contrasts with the background and is near the action button.
- Clearly tie the action to the agreement by wording such as "By clicking Submit, you agree to..."
- Make hyperlinks look like links, using color or capitalization.
- Maintain records of the exact version of the page viewed by each consumer. The court assumed the defendants' recreations were accurate but noted they were disputed.
- Apply similar design standards to TCPA consent language, which is subject to its own scrutiny.
Read the Ninth Circuit's opinion in Berman v. Freedom Financial Network.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
