Case analysis · Calls & text messages
A Text Message Doesn't Have a Voice: Ninth Circuit Tosses "Prerecorded Voice" Theory for Texts
Here's a fun one.
On this page
Can a text message contain a "prerecorded voice"? One plaintiff argued yes. Her theory: "voice" can mean "an instrument or medium of expression," and a pre-written text is a medium of expression. So, prerecorded voice.
Creative? Sure. Did it work? Nope.
So what happened?
Around April 14, 2020, Lucine Trim received a text message from an unknown number stating: "Hiya Lucine, you are a valuable customer. In these tough times, let us [] reimburse [you] for your shopping needs." It linked to a Reward Zone USA LLC promo site where people complete "Deals" to claim prizes.
Trim says she was never a Reward Zone customer and never gave her number to Reward Zone or its lead vendor. She got at least two more similar texts within 12 months.
She filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). One claim said the texts used an autodialer. Another said they used a "prerecorded voice." The district court dismissed both with prejudice.
The ruling
In Trim v. Reward Zone USA LLC, No. 22-55517, 76 F.4th 1157 (9th Cir. Aug. 8, 2023), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit affirmed on the voice claim. Judge N. Randy Smith wrote the opinion. (The autodialer claim was handled in a separate, unpublished ruling.)
The TCPA bars calls to cell phones using "any automatic telephone dialing system or an artificial or prerecorded voice" without consent. 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(1)(A)(iii).
Here's the thing ... the court held that "voice" means an audible sound. Period.
- Ordinary meaning. Dictionaries from 1991 define voice as sound from the larynx. The "medium of expression" definitions came later in the list and showed up in poetic examples.
- Statutory context. The TCPA separately mentions "a voice service" and "a text message sent using a text messaging service." If voice covered texts, the text language would be pointless.
- The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) doesn't help. The Ninth Circuit has followed the FCC's view that a text is a "call." But both the court and the FCC distinguish "text calls" from "voice calls."
The Ninth Circuit’s embedded-video text decision
And a fun footnote: the court noted that a multimedia text (MMS) with an audio clip could include an artificial or prerecorded voice. So don't get cute.
Why should you care?
Look, this is good news for texters. One fewer theory to worry about.
But read that again: the claims about texting people on the Do Not Call Registry weren't part of this appeal. Those are a whole separate problem. And texting people who say they never gave you their number? That's how lawsuits start, whatever the legal theory.
What to do this week
- Know where your lead vendor's numbers come from. Ask for proof of consent.
- Scrub against the Do Not Call Registry before any marketing text.
- Be careful with MMS audio. A recorded voice clip changes the analysis.
- Keep consent records tied to the exact number texted.
Pro tip: if your text starts with "you are a valuable customer," make sure they're actually your customer. That's it.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
