Analysis · Do Not Call
Nichols v. eHealthInsurance: You Don't Have to Be the One Who Put Your Number on the Do-Not-Call List
Picture this: you get a new phone number, and someone else registered it on the National Do-Not-Call Registry years ago. Telemarketers start calling. Can you sue? A federal judge in San Jose said yes. In Nichols v. eHealthInsurance Services, Inc., No. 23-cv-06720-EKL (N.D. Cal. Mar. 3, 2025), Judge Eumi K. Lee held that a plaintiff does not have to allege that he personally registered his number.
On this page
The Setup
The remaining named plaintiff (a co-plaintiff had voluntarily dismissed) alleged that his cell number "was added" to the registry in August 2021 and that the online insurance marketplace placed several telemarketing calls to it in June and July 2022 without consent or an existing business relationship. He sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and its do-not-call rules on behalf of a nationwide class.
Count 1: Oops
The complaint included references to an autodialer and prerecorded messages. The plaintiff admitted those were included "inadvertently," and his counsel agreed at the hearing that the count could go. The court dismissed it without leave to amend.
Count 2: The Registry Lists Numbers, Not Names
The marketplace argued the plaintiff had to allege that he personally registered the number. The court disagreed for three reasons.
The statute. Congress directed rules prohibiting telephone solicitations "to the telephone number of any subscriber included in the database." Quoting Hall v. Smosh Dot Com, Inc., 72 F.4th 983 (9th Cir. 2023), the court noted, "The Do-Not-Call Registry lists numbers, not names." The private right of action covers any "person who has received" the calls.
The rules. Registrations "must be honored indefinitely," or until the consumer cancels or the administrator removes the number. Protection follows the number.
The safe harbors. The rules put the burden on telemarketers to prove a listed defense, such as error-prevention procedures or consent. None covers "the person who picked up didn't register it." Requiring personal registration would invent a new one.
The court observed that nearly every court to consider the issue has agreed, and refused to follow the one outlier (an Iowa federal decision that read a single sentence of the rule in isolation).
The Class Gets a Rewrite
The proposed class covered people who received two or more "telephone solicitations." That sounds harmless, but the rules define a telephone solicitation to exclude calls made with consent or to someone with an existing business relationship. So deciding who is in the class would require deciding the merits, which makes it a forbidden "fail-safe" class. The court struck it but showed the fix: swap "telephone solicitations" for "telephone calls."
The marketplace's other attacks failed. It argued the class was overbroad because some members might have consented, but it offered no evidence, and the court noted the tension with its fail-safe argument. Including calls by third parties on behalf of the company was fine, because those parties could be identified in discovery. And a class including people who did not personally register their numbers was not overbroad, for the reasons above.
Takeaways
- For callers: Scrub against the registry by number. Who registered it does not matter, and registrations do not expire.
- For plaintiffs: Avoid regulatory terms of art like "telephone solicitation" in class definitions. Plain "telephone calls" works better.
- For everyone: Proofread your complaint before filing.
Shelton v. EMPWR Solar: No Proof of Registration, No Do Not Call Claim
Read the Northern District of California order in Nichols v. eHealthInsurance.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Order Granting in Part Motion to Dismiss and Motion to Strike Class Allegations, Nichols v. eHealthInsurance Services, Inc., No. 23-cv-06720-EKL (N.D. Cal. Mar. 3, 2025)
- Hall v. Smosh Dot Com, Inc., 72 F.4th 983 (9th Cir. 2023)
- Order Granting in Part Motion to Dismiss and Motion to Strike Class Allegations, Nichols v. eHealthInsurance Services, Inc., No. 23-cv-06720-EKL (N.D. Cal. Mar. 3, 2025).
