Analysis · Do Not Call
Murch v. GPS Capital Markets: Individual Do Not Call Claim Survives a Misdirected Business Call, but Class Allegations Do Not
In Murch v. GPS Capital Markets, LLC, No. 3:24-cv-01854-SB (D. Or. June 6, 2025), Magistrate Judge Beckerman recommended that the district judge deny a foreign exchange brokerage's standing and pleading challenges to a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) Do Not Call claim, but dismiss the injunctive relief claim and dismiss or strike the class allegations. The call at issue was aimed at a business executive and reached the plaintiff instead.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff alleged that her number had been on the National Do Not Call Registry for more than 31 days, that she used it for residential purposes, and that the defendant called it three times in five days in late 2024. She answered only the third call. The caller asked for a business executive, described the company as "the nation's largest foreign exchange brokerage," and asked her to pass along that they would like to speak to him or someone at his company. The plaintiff provided a different name, and offered to take the message. The defendant submitted evidence of only selling to businesses.
Standing Intertwined With the Merits
The defendant raised a factual standing challenge, asserting that the plaintiff received no telephone solicitation and suffered no injury. Because the TCPA supplies both jurisdiction and the claim, and the parties disputed the call's purpose, the question was intertwined with the merits and could not be resolved on the motion. The argument that the plaintiff was not the person being solicited was a variation on the "intended recipient" defense, which the Ninth Circuit rejected in N.L. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., 960 F.3d 1164 (9th Cir. 2020).
The Individual Claim Was Plausibly Pled
- More than one solicitation. The content and timing of the answered call supported an inference that the two unanswered calls from the same number shared its purpose.
- Telephone solicitation. Promoting the company as the largest foreign exchange brokerage and seeking anyone interested plausibly showed a purpose of encouraging a purchase, even though the transcript showed no offer to the plaintiff herself.
- Registration. Following the majority view in the circuit, the plaintiff did not need to allege that she personally registered the number. Registrations are honored indefinitely until cancelled or removed.
Injunctive Relief Dismissed
Three calls over five days, no stop request, and no later calls showed only a possible future injury.
Class Allegations Rejected
The recommendation found this one of the rare cases warranting dismissal of class allegations at the pleading stage. The record showed a business-to-business seller that mistakenly reached the plaintiff, while trying to call a published business number. In the alternative, the class allegations should be stricken, because the plaintiff did not fall within her own definition, which required calls "encouraging the purchase of GPS's goods or services" by the recipient, and because membership turned on the merits question of each call's purpose. Leave to amend within 14 days was recommended. Otherwise, the case would proceed individually.
Practical Implications
Business-to-business callers are not exempt when a published business number turns out to be a registered residential line, and the intended recipient argument is unlikely to defeat standing. But a misdirected business call is a weak foundation for a consumer class. Plaintiffs need facts suggesting others were similarly called, and class definitions should rely on objective criteria rather than the legal characterization of each call.
Newell v. JR Capital: A Caller ID Win, Then a Business Number Loss
Read the District of Oregon findings and recommendation in Murch v. GPS Capital Markets.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
