Case analysis · Calls & text messages

Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial: One Fax, Two Violations

In Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial & Insurance Services, No. 14-11036, 780 F.3d 1101 (11th Cir. Mar. 13, 2015), the Eleventh Circuit held that a single fax can count as two separate violations of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), each worth $500, when it breaks two distinct prohibitions. The court also clarified what a plaintiff needs to show to get treble damages.

By Adam YoungPublished 2 min read
On this page

What happened

Dr. John Lary, representing himself, sued Trinity Physician Financial & Insurance Services and its owner, Joseph Hong. He alleged they used an automatic telephone dialing system to send a fax ad to the fax machine on his medical facility's emergency telephone line on October 2, 2012. He claimed two violations, one for autodialing an emergency line and one for the unsolicited fax ad, and asked for $1,500 for each.

The defendants withdrew their defense and accepted a default judgment. In his motion for default judgment, Lary added a second fax from March 5. The Northern District of Alabama awarded $1,000: $500 for each of the two faxes, treating each fax as a single violation. It denied treble damages, an injunction, discovery and costs.

What the court held

Judge William Pryor wrote for the panel.

Each prohibition is a separate violation. Section 227(b)(1) lists distinct prohibitions. Autodialing an emergency line is a violation no matter what the message says. Sending an unsolicited fax ad is a violation no matter what line it goes to. The damages provision awards $500 for "each such violation," and the court traced that phrase to "a violation of this subsection." Nothing limits recovery to one award per call or fax.

But the error was harmless. A default judgment can't go beyond the complaint, and the complaint alleged only the October fax. The correct award was $1,000 for two violations from that one fax. That's the same amount Lary already received.

Treble damages need knowledge of the violating facts. Treble damages require a "willful or knowing" violation, meaning the defendant knew it was engaging in the conduct that violates the statute. For the emergency line claim, the defendant must know it was autodialing an emergency line. For the fax claim, it must know the ad was unsolicited. Lary alleged neither fact. In fact, his own affidavit said Hong used a third party to send faxes, which suggests the defendants may not have known about his fax at all. Calling the conduct "willful" was a legal conclusion, which a default doesn't admit.

Other relief. Lary showed no likelihood of future harm, so no injunction. His discovery motions came after the deadline. And he never asked the clerk for costs as the local rules required.

The court affirmed.

Why this matters

TCPA exposure can multiply when one transmission breaks more than one rule. Fax campaigns that reach emergency or hospital lines are especially risky.

Practical points

  1. Keep fax and dialing lists free of emergency and healthcare lines.
  2. Plaintiffs should plead every violation and every transmission in the complaint.
  3. Treble damages need specific factual allegations about what the defendant knew.
  4. Follow the local rules to recover costs.

Read the Eleventh Circuit's opinion in Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Opinion, Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial & Insurance Services, No. 14-11036 (11th Cir. Mar. 13, 2015)
  2. Opinion, Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial & Insurance Services, No. 14-11036 (11th Cir. Mar. 13, 2015) (2)
  3. Opinion, Lary v. Trinity Physician Financial & Insurance Services, No. 14-11036 (11th Cir. Mar. 13, 2015).
Adam Young, CEO of Ringba, Miami, Florida

About the Author: Adam Young

Adam Young is a 42-year-old entrepreneur from Miami, Florida. He is the CEO of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform. Adam Young has been in telecom, call routing and performance marketing for over a decade, and is the author of The Pay Per Call Revolution. At TCPA.com, Adam Young writes about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), robocall enforcement, tech support fraud cases and what actions by the Department of Justice (DOJ), Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mean for companies that make calls. His goal is to help companies stay compliant and keep scammers off the phone network.

More from Adam Young

Topics