Analysis · Do Not Call
109 Million Calls, One Coupon Site, and a $1 Million Lesson in Consent
I don't know about you, but my phone rings off the hook. Unknown numbers. "Amber." "Audrey." Somebody swearing I asked about something I never asked about.
On this page
Well, here's a case where the federal government says it knows who was behind a big pile of those calls.
On September 30, 2025, the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a complaint in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts against Citizens Disability, LLC and its subsidiary CD Media, LLC. The DOJ filed upon notification and referral from the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). Along with the complaint came a proposed consent order with a $2 million civil penalty, partially suspended once the companies pay a total of $1 million.
The number that caught my eye? 109 million.
Read that again.
So what happened?
Citizens Disability is based in Waltham, Massachusetts. According to the complaint, it guides consumers applying for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits and represents them before the Social Security Administration (SSA). CD Media is its wholly owned subsidiary, and the complaint lists a long series of names the companies allegedly did business under, like National Disability, American Disability Helpline and United States Disability.
Here's what the government is alleging:
- Between January 2019 and July 2022, the companies and their call centers initiated over 109 million outbound telemarketing calls.
- Over 25.7 million of those calls were to numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry at the time of the call.
- The companies and their agents made millions of prerecorded robocalls, some using soundboard technology, and allegedly left voicemails on the first, fifth and tenth dial attempts to the same person.
- Some robocalls allegedly opened with lines like "Hi. My name is Amber" or "Hello, my name is Audrey" followed by a claim that the person had recently inquired about their eligibility for Social Security Disability benefits. The government says those people hadn't.
- The FTC's Consumer Sentinel database had over 10,000 complaints about Do Not Call violations and over 700 about robocalls tied to the companies, per the complaint.
The legal claims arise under the FTC Act and the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR). There are five counts: misrepresentation, unlawful prerecorded messages, calling numbers on the Registry, not paying the fee to access the Registry and not keeping required records. You can read the whole thing yourself in the full DOJ complaint against Citizens Disability.
None of this has been proven at trial. These are allegations, and the companies settled the matter through the proposed order.
Here's the thing ... the leads
This is the part that should make every lead gen and pay-per-call person sit up straight.
According to the complaint, approximately 90 percent of the companies' leads from January 2019 to May 2023 came from third-party lead generators. The companies worked with over 50 lead generators and more than 15 call centers since 2019. And the leads allegedly came from "consent farm" websites, which the complaint describes as sites that mostly exist to generate leads for sale.
The complaint walks through two examples in detail.
One was a coupon site. Big "FREE COUPONS" messaging, a giant green CONTINUE button, and then, in what the complaint calls "disproportionately small font", a line saying you agree to be contacted by phone even if you're on a Do Not Call list. The complaint says the site never mentioned the defendants at all.
The other was a sweepstakes site. "Where should we send YOUR $50,000.00 if you win?" and a big blue CONFIRM YOUR ENTRY button with the consent language in small print, blue text on a blue background. Click "Marketing Partners" and, per the complaint, you got a list of roughly 290 companies from totally unrelated industries.
I get it. Someone sold you a list and swore it was "fully opted in." But the government's position here is that consent for calls to Registry numbers and for robocalls has to be for a specific seller. A coupon form that never names you, or a sweepstakes entry that "approves" 290 companies at once, isn't that, according to the complaint.
And here's another thing ... the government is also alleging that the lead generators and call centers were acting as the companies' agents. Some contracts allegedly required them to use scripts the companies provided. So "the vendor did it" is not the shield people think it is.
Why should you care?
Because this is how a lot of the industry buys traffic. Am I right?
If you're a seller, a buyer of calls, a call center or a lead gen shop, the theory in this case lands right on your desk. Even if you never dialed a single number yourself, the government is saying your agents' calls are your calls.
And notice who they focused on. The complaint says the companies targeted people between 50 and 64, people who were unemployed, and people not already getting disability benefits. The FTC said that many of the people called were lower income or disabled. Those are people who pick up expecting help. If the allegations are true, calling them with a made-up "you inquired about this" line is just bad behavior. Don't do it.
What the order requires
According to the FTC's announcement, the proposed order:
- Bans the companies from certain telemarketing with prerecorded robocalls
- Bans certain telemarketing to numbers on the Do Not Call Registry
- Bans misrepresentations including claiming they're calling because the consumer asked about disability benefits
- Requires due diligence and monitoring of their lead generators
- Sets a $2 million penalty, partially suspended after $1 million in payments within a year. If the companies are found to have misrepresented their finances, the full amount is due.
That due diligence piece is the real story for the rest of us. Read the FTC's press release on the Citizens Disability settlement if you want the agency's own words.
What to do this week
It's not rocket science. It's just the boring parts.
- Know where every lead comes from. The actual website. The actual form. Screenshot it. If the page is all coupons and sweepstakes, ask hard questions.
- Make sure your name is on the consent. If the consent language doesn't name your company, or names you alongside a few hundred others, assume it won't hold.
- Scrub against the Do Not Call Registry and pay for the access you need. One of the counts here is literally about not paying the Registry fee.
- Kill fake familiarity in scripts. "It shows here you inquired" is only OK if they actually inquired. Otherwise it's a misrepresentation.
- Keep records. Who was called, when, from what number, whether it was transferred and to whom. One of the five counts is about recordkeeping.
- Audit your vendors like they're you. Because according to this complaint, they are.
A quick confession
I've lit plenty of money on fire in my life. Bad ads, bad hires, wrong bets. But every one of those mistakes hurt me, not some guy at home waiting on a disability check. That's the difference. When the person on the other end of the call is vulnerable, the stakes are not just your margin.
So check your sources, OK?
Do the boring stuff. It's what keeps the fun stuff alive.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
