Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Wolfe v. GoodVets: "11:45 P.M. Are You Serious? STOP!" and a Vet's Text Problem
Most of us like a reminder that our dog is due for shots. Most of us don't like getting it at 11:45 at night. In Wolfe v. GoodVets Veterinary Services LLC, No. CV-26-02836-PHX-MTL (D. Ariz. June 25, 2026), a dog owner's Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) claims against her veterinarian largely survived a motion to dismiss. One claim, based on a Federal Trade Commission rule, did not.
On this page
The Texts
GoodVets treated the plaintiff's dog, Tater Tot, in March 2025. Follow-up emails about his recovery came next, followed by automated texts about vaccines, dental care, the clinic's referral program and its hours. Each text said, "Text STOP to opt-out." The plaintiff said she didn't recall giving written permission to be texted.
On August 20, one arrived at 11:45 p.m. Three days later, she replied: "11:45 P.M. Are you serious? STOP!" The system answered right away: "We received your message. Did you mean to unsubscribe? Reply STOP to opt out of all messages." She didn't send a standalone "STOP."
The texts continued, with twelve more through January 2026. She sent two demand letters asking for the clinic's internal do-not-call policy. Three more texts followed. She sued, focusing on the post-"STOP!" texts and the late-night text.
Consent Is the Defendant's Burden
GoodVets argued that she had consented as a customer and the only real question was whether she revoked that consent. The court explained that in the Ninth Circuit, consent is an affirmative defense, not something a plaintiff must disprove in the complaint. The cases GoodVets cited involved plaintiffs who clearly consented. Here, nothing in the complaint showed consent that was "clearly and unmistakably stated." Taking a pet in for treatment and not objecting to emails didn't meet that standard on a motion to dismiss. Claims based on texts after August 23 survived.
The Quiet Hours Text
Federal rules bar telephone solicitations before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m. GoodVets made two arguments:
- Permission. This failed for the same reason: consent wasn't established from the complaint.
- One text isn't enough. The private right of action requires more than one violating call in 12 months. The court counted together the late-night text and the post-"STOP!" texts to a number on the National Do Not Call Registry. Both rules are in the same Do Not Call regulation adopted under Section 227(c), so violations of either count toward the threshold.
The Policy Request Claim
The plaintiff also claimed GoodVets violated the Federal Trade Commission's Telemarketing Sales Rule by not sending its do-not-call policy. That rule is enforced only by the Federal Trade Commission and state attorneys general, so the claim was dismissed with prejudice.
Takeaways
- Watch the clock. A single late-night text can support a quiet hours claim when combined with other violations.
- Different Do Not Call violations can be counted together. Quiet hours and registry violations both count toward the two-call threshold.
- "Customer" doesn't mean "consented." A care relationship doesn't establish express consent at the pleading stage.
- Make opt-outs easy. The complaint challenged the texts sent after a "STOP!" reply that the system flagged but didn't treat as an opt-out.
- Telemarketing Sales Rule claims aren't private. Only regulators can enforce it.
Jones v. Safr Technologies on early-morning texts
Read the District of Arizona order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
