Analysis · Do Not Call
New York's Department of State Uses Consent Orders to Police Do Not Call Violations
Not every state telemarketing case goes to court. In New York, the Department of State (DOS), through its Division of Consumer Protection, enforces the state's Do Not Call law, General Business Law section 399-z, largely through administrative consent orders. Three recent orders show how the process works: Legal Growth Marketing, Inc. (2024), Odyssey Insurance Agency LLC (2025) and Omind Technologies, Inc. (2025).
On this page
The bottom line: New York can reach "all controlling persons" behind a telemarketer, and a missed payment sends the matter to the Attorney General for the full statutory penalty.
The three orders
- Legal Growth Marketing, Inc. (Case No. 2024-C-052908). The company did not contest violations of section 399-z(5): making or causing unsolicited telemarketing sales calls to New Yorkers whose numbers had been on the National Do Not Call Registry for at least 31 days. The company agreed to pay a $50,000 civil penalty by November 20, 2024. The investigation would close only if, among other conditions, the company committed no section 399-z violations for three years and registered as a New York telemarketer before any future telemarketing.
- Odyssey Insurance Agency LLC (listed as Case No. 2024-C-093001). Odyssey settled the same type of alleged Do Not Call violations as a disputed matter, for a $44,000 civil penalty paid in six monthly installments from July 30 through December 30, 2025. Its controlling persons signed an attestation and personal guarantee.
- Omind Technologies, Inc. (Case No. 2025-C-032001). The largest of the three. Omind agreed to a $250,000 civil penalty: $10,000 by December 28, 2025, then $5,000 a month for 48 months. It must also register as a telemarketer in New York before any further telemarketing there.
Common terms
Each order follows a similar pattern:
- The trigger: each action began with complaints received by DOS.
- The promise: the respondent will not call a New York resident registered on the national Do Not Call Registry for at least 31 days without documented consent or an express request. The Legal Growth and Odyssey orders add that a consumer's consent applies only to the specific entity named in it.
- The reach: the orders apply to the company and all "controlling persons," including parents, members, managers and principals.
- The hammer: under each order, a default results in referral to the New York Attorney General to collect the full civil penalty for each violation under section 399-z(14)(a).
- No hearing: each respondent waived its right to an administrative hearing.
Why this matters
These are not Attorney General lawsuits. They are administrative settlements by a separate state agency. But they show a steady enforcement channel that many telemarketers overlook. DOS publishes its consent orders, and its list includes lead generators, insurance agencies, mortgage lenders, home improvement companies and warranty sellers.
What this means for you
- Consent must name you. Two of these orders say consent covers only the entity identified in it. A shared lead form listing "partners" may not be enough.
- Register before you dial. All three orders make New York telemarketer registration a condition of future telemarketing.
- Expect personal guarantees. Odyssey's controlling persons signed one.
- Payment plans are available, but default is costly. Missing a payment may trigger referral for the full statutory penalty.
- Complaints drive cases. Consumer complaints started each of these investigations.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
