Case analysis · Consent & revocation
Eleventh Circuit Vacates the FCC's One-to-One Consent Rule
The bottom line: on January 24, 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit held in Insurance Marketing Coalition Limited v. Federal Communications Commission, No. 24-10277, that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) exceeded its statutory authority under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) when it adopted new consent restrictions in Part III.D of its 2023 Order. The court vacated that part of the order and remanded.
On this page
The opinion is attached: Eleventh Circuit opinion vacating the FCC one-to-one consent rule.
What happened
The TCPA generally requires that a caller have the "prior express consent" of the called party to make a robocall. Since 2012, FCC rules have required prior express written consent for robocalls that are telemarketing or advertising.
In 2023, the FCC adopted two additional restrictions on telemarketing and advertising robocalls and robotexts:
- One-to-one consent. Consent had to be provided to one identified seller at a time.
- Logical and topical association. The calls had to be "logically and topically associated with the interaction that prompted the consent."
Insurance Marketing Coalition Limited (IMC), a consortium of more than 20 insurance marketing stakeholders, including lead generators, challenged the rule. It argued the rule exceeded the FCC's authority, violated the First Amendment and was arbitrary and capricious.
What the court held
The panel (Judges Branch, Luck and Lagoa; opinion by Judge Branch) agreed with IMC on the first ground. The new restrictions "impermissibly conflict with the ordinary statutory meaning of 'prior express consent.'" Because that ground decided the case, the court vacated Part III.D.
The court noted that the lead generation industry is the industry most affected by the 2023 Order.
Why it matters
The one-to-one rule would have ended the practice of collecting a single consent for many sellers on comparison shopping sites. With Part III.D vacated, that rule does not take effect.
That does not mean every consent obtained on a lead form is valid. Consent must still be "prior express consent" under the statute, and prior express written consent for telemarketing under the 2012 rule. Courts and regulators continue to closely scrutinize consent obtained through lead forms that list many companies.
What this means for you
- The 2012 written consent rule still applies. Keep signed, clear consents for telemarketing robocalls and robotexts.
- Clear disclosure still matters. Consent hidden in fine print, or shared with hundreds of unrelated sellers, invites challenge.
- Watch state law. Some states have their own consent requirements.
- Keep records. Keep the form, the disclosure language, the timestamp and the seller list for each lead.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
